Whistleblowing and the Importance of Proving Motive – Guideline Ruling

Establishing that an employee has made a protected disclosure is the first step on the path to success in any whistleblowing claim. However, as a case concerning a dismissed care homes manager showed, it is often much harder to prove that detrimental treatment is motivated by such a…

Mar 16, 2023

Vlad sargu itphh2lgzui unsplash 1024x683

Establishing that an employee has made a protected disclosure is the first step on the path to success in any whistleblowing claim. However, as a case concerning a dismissed care homes manager showed, it is often much harder to prove that detrimental treatment is motivated by such a disclosure.

The woman had been in post for only about six months when she was dismissed at the end of her probationary period. Her employer asserted that she was dismissed on grounds of capability or performance. She contended, however, that the motive underlying her dismissal was that she had made protected disclosures by raising concerns that understaffing was putting residents’ safety at risk.

Following a hearing, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that she had made a single protected disclosure. In rejecting her claim of automatic unfair dismissal, however, it found that the disclosure played no part whatsoever in the decision to terminate her contract. The decision-maker was wholly uninfluenced by the disclosure and the reason for her dismissal was, as the employer contended, her lack of capability.

Upholding her challenge to that outcome, the Employment Appeal Tribunal noted that the decision-maker had in part relied on a probation report prepared by the woman’s former line manager. It was the central plank of the woman’s case that it was the report that prompted her dismissal and that, in writing it, the line manager was herself influenced by the disclosure.

In asking itself whether the disclosure was the principal reason for her dismissal, the ET was thus required explicitly to consider the motives of not only the decision-maker but also the line manager. The ET had not spelt out in its decision that it had taken that course. The issue was sent back to the same, or a similarly constituted, ET for fresh consideration.

Waitress Accused of Stealing from the Till Succeeds in Unfair Dismissal Claim

A genuine and honest belief that an employee is guilty of gross misconduct is not, by itself, a viable defence to an unfair dismissal claim. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in awarding compensation to a restaurant waitress who was sacked after being accused of pilfering money from the till. On reviewing the restaurant’s accounts, its owner said he discovered that till receipts were down by modest but round figures on a number of days. Referring to his diary entries, he asserted that…

Skiing Company Fined After Boy’s Tragic Death at Birthday Party

An indoor skiing company has received a £100,000 fine following an accident in which a 12-year-old boy died. The boy was at a tobogganing party to celebrate a friend’s birthday. He was descending the main ski slope on a toboggan when it ran into the back of a member of staff who was conducting a slope walk. The member of staff fell backwards onto the boy, who tragically died at the scene from head injuries. An investigation by the Health and Safety Executive found that the company had failed to…

Right to Disconnect

Article from the Financial News - Friday August 27th 2021 When the pandemic struck, many businesses were forced to remove staff from the office and set them up at home at short notice. In the past 17 months, businesses have worked effectively with staff working from home. Productivity has increased, and staff have found that a more flexible working pattern has enabled a better work-life balance for many. Now that home schooling has become a distant memory, we hear that parents, grandparents and…