Workplace Disciplinary Proceedings – Empathy and Understanding Required

The critical issue in many employment cases is whether an employee’s dismissal lies within the range of reasonable responses open to the employer. As an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruling showed, the answer to that question often depends on the level of empathy and understanding shown in…

Nov 23, 2021

Pexels pixabay 256541 1024x682

The critical issue in many employment cases is whether an employee’s dismissal lies within the range of reasonable responses open to the employer. As an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruling showed, the answer to that question often depends on the level of empathy and understanding shown in the disciplinary process.

The case concerned a university library employee who was working alone behind the reception desk when, as she was entitled to do, she asked a student to show her photo identity card. The student was rude, disrespectful and aggressive towards her, accusing her of racism. Further incidents followed during which the woman found herself surrounded by students, one of whom had to be restrained.

Following a disciplinary hearing, she was dismissed on grounds of gross misconduct. The decision-maker described her conduct as antagonistic, inappropriate, negative from the outset and deeply unprofessional. After her internal appeal was rejected, she launched Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings.

Ruling on the matter, the ET found that the university had a potentially fair reason for dismissing her. The investigation into her conduct was apparently conducted with an open mind and the decision-maker had reasonable grounds for forming a genuine belief that she was guilty of misconduct. The procedure followed was also fair.

In upholding her unfair dismissal claim, however, the ET was struck by the apparent lack of empathy and understanding for the situation in which she found herself. The incidents had caused her a great deal of distress but it did not seem to have crossed the decision-maker’s mind that, in the absence of her supervisor, she was out of her depth and quite simply overwhelmed by the situation.

The disciplinary hearing understandably focused on the woman’s conduct, but very little if any account was taken of the students’ behaviour. There did not appear to have been proper consideration of the provocation to which she was subjected. She had no formal blot on her disciplinary record and, in those circumstances, the decision to dismiss her fell outside the range of reasonable responses.

By her own culpable conduct, the ET found that she made a 65 per cent contribution to her dismissal. After becoming angry, she did not deal well with the situation. She did not walk away as quickly as she should have done and at one point pretended to use her mobile phone to photograph students. It was inappropriate and unreasonable for her to behave in that manner. Following a 65 per cent discount, the university was ordered to pay her £4,730 in damages.

Logistics Operative Succeeds in Post-Termination Victimisation Complaint

Victimisation of workers does not necessarily come to an end with the termination of their employment. The point was made by the case of a logistics operative who was labelled a troublemaker by a member of his former employer’s senior management team. Whilst working for his former employer, the operative, who suffered from anxiety and depression, lodged a grievance and issued an Employment Tribunal (ET) complaint of disability discrimination. Both those steps were agreed to be protected acts.…

Company Directors – You Need to Act to Secure Your Employment Rights

Company directors with imperfect knowledge of employment law all too often fail to confer upon themselves the basic legal protections to which even their most junior members of staff are entitled. In a case on point, a businessman found himself in a very weak position following his removal from the company he co-founded. The man was a 45 per cent shareholder and director of the company, which thrived in its early days, employing about 80 staff and turning over around £1.8 million. As its…

Employer Cleared of Liability for Disruptive Pupil’s Attack on Teacher

Teaching troubled children whose behaviour may be challenging, even violent, is not for the faint hearted. However, as the Court of Appeal emphasised in an important ruling, schools can only do what is reasonable to protect staff from injury. The case concerned a teacher who was injured when a six-year-old child became violent whilst being segregated in a room set aside for calming down disruptive pupils. Her soft tissue injuries healed within weeks, but she lodged a substantial compensation…