Workplace Horseplay and Employers’ Responsibilities – Guideline Ruling

Irresponsible horseplay in the workplace can cause serious injury, but to what extent should employers be held indirectly – or vicariously – liable for such behaviour? The Court of Appeal considered that burning issue in a guideline case.

A fitter was bending down to pick up a length of…

Jan 20, 2022

Law books and judge gavel 1024x683

Irresponsible horseplay in the workplace can cause serious injury, but to what extent should employers be held indirectly – or vicariously – liable for such behaviour? The Court of Appeal considered that burning issue in a guideline case.

A fitter was bending down to pick up a length of steel when a workmate placed two pellet targets on a bench close to his right ear. The workmate struck the targets with a hammer, causing a loud explosion. As a result, the fitter suffered noise-induced hearing loss in his right ear and tinnitus.

He launched a compensation claim against the company that employed the other man and operated and controlled the site where the incident occurred. His claim was, however, rejected on the basis that the company bore neither direct nor vicarious responsibility for the other man’s practical joke.

Rejecting his challenge to that outcome, the Court noted that the targets had been brought onto the site by the other man and were not part of the work equipment provided by the company. He had no supervisory or other role in respect of the fitter’s work and his wrongful act was not authorised by the company or carried out in the course of his employment. It was therefore neither just, fair nor reasonable to impose vicarious liability on the company.

The Court noted that the fitter and his team were external contractors. There was some friction between them and other workers directly employed by the company. There was, however, no suggestion that those tensions had previously resulted in actual violence or threats of violence. It could not be said that the incident was reasonably foreseeable by the company.

It was unrealistic to suggest that the company should have specifically instructed workers on the site not to engage in horseplay. That went without saying in that common sense decreed that such behaviour was inappropriate. There was in any event a site rule in place that forbade workers from intentionally or recklessly misusing equipment. That was a warning against exactly what the other man did.

Man Who Worked for Membership Association Was an Employee

The Employment Tribunal (ET) has ruled that a man who worked for a membership association which acted on behalf of free-range egg producers was an employee rather than a self-employed contractor. The man began working for the association in 2011 as Policy Director, going on to become Chief Executive in 2016. He was required to work a set number of days per week and invoiced the association monthly for the work he had performed, plus travel and accommodation expenses. In March 2023 he was given…

Dismissal of ‘Anti-Zionist’ Council Employee Ruled Unfair

Employers may come under external pressure to take disciplinary action against an employee, but that is all the more reason to follow a scrupulously fair procedure. The point was made by the case of a council employee who became the focus of media attention after participating in a demonstration outside Parliament. The man worked in the council’s environmental health department. His role was not considered politically sensitive and he was free to attend demonstrations and to state his political…

COVID-19 – Carer Sacked After Visiting Pub Wins Unfair Dismissal Claim

The pressure put on many employment relationships by COVID-19 was illustrated by the case of a care worker who was sacked by her vulnerable charge’s mother after she went to the pub in the very early stages of the pandemic. The carer was one of a team employed by the mother to look after her daughter, who suffers from cerebral palsy and is particularly susceptible to infection. On Friday, 20 March 2020, she went to the pub with her partner and a friend. At almost exactly the same time, the…