Employment Judge’s Interventions Gave Rise to Apparent Bias – EAT Ruling

Judges are entitled to robustly manage the cases that come before them, but what they cannot do is give even an impression that they are taking sides. In a case on point, an employment judge’s interventions during a hotly contested hearing were found to have crossed the line into apparent…

Apr 19, 2023

Pexels mart production 7643794 1024x683

Judges are entitled to robustly manage the cases that come before them, but what they cannot do is give even an impression that they are taking sides. In a case on point, an employment judge’s interventions during a hotly contested hearing were found to have crossed the line into apparent bias.

Following a hearing, which was held via video link during the COVID-19 pandemic, the employment judge upheld an office administrator’s complaint of constructive unfair dismissal. The employer challenged his decision before the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT), asserting that his interventions indicated that he had pre-determined important issues in the case.

Ruling on the matter, the EAT rejected most of the employer’s complaints. The employment judge was anxious to ensure that the claimant, who was acting in person, was not disadvantaged by her lack of legal representation. Most of his interventions fell into the category of legitimate case management.

In allowing the appeal, however, the EAT found that some of his remarks suggested that he had made up his mind on certain points before hearing full evidence. He had, amongst other things, questioned the employment law experience of the employer’s representative in an uncalled-for and pejorative manner and had expressed a preliminary view that the employer’s case on one issue was hopeless.

Adopting the neutral position of an informed and impartial observer, the EAT found that certain of the employment judge’s interventions gave rise to an appearance of bias. On at least three occasions during the hearing, he gave the appearance of having taken a side. The EAT directed a fresh hearing of the case before a differently constituted Employment Tribunal.

Unfairly Dismissed? You Must Take Reasonable Steps to Mitigate Your Loss

Those who are unfairly dismissed are required to take reasonable steps to mitigate their financial loss, usually by hunting for a new job. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in the case of a woman who made not one application for fresh employment in the three years after she was sacked. The woman, who worked for a financial services company, launched Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings after she was dismissed, purportedly on grounds of redundancy. Following a liability…

Severe Menopausal Symptoms Can Amount to a Disability, ET Rules

The word ‘disability’ may summon images of people suffering from grave physical incapacity but, in employment law terms, it has a much broader meaning than that. In an employment case on point, a woman who was suffering from the ill effects of the menopause met the statutory definition of disability. The woman, who was in her 50s, suffered physical symptoms including hot flushes, night sweats, headaches, joint pain and tingling extremities. Mentally, she endured anxiety, panic attacks,…

Industrial Accident Victim Receives £350,000 in Compensation

Despite rigorous health and safety improvements over the years, industrial accidents are still not as rare as they could be. However, as a High Court case showed, it is a personal injury lawyer’s mission in life to expose negligence and ensure that victims are justly compensated. The case concerned a middle-aged plant operator whose left arm was crushed as he attempted to retrieve a piece of metal that had become caught in a heavy machine. He needed extensive skin grafts and underwent a…