Whistleblower Treated as ‘Complainer’ Receives Substantial Compensation

Whistleblowers perform a vital role in the public interest and managers who persist in viewing their activities merely as inconvenient belly-aching expose themselves to condemnation by Employment Tribunals (ETs). That was certainly so in the case of a warehouse worker whose health and safety…

Feb 09, 2022

Pexels tiger lily 4481323 1024x683

Whistleblowers perform a vital role in the public interest and managers who persist in viewing their activities merely as inconvenient belly-aching expose themselves to condemnation by Employment Tribunals (ETs). That was certainly so in the case of a warehouse worker whose health and safety concerns were ignored.

The man reported a number of health and safety issues to his managers. Amongst other things, he noticed that cardboard and pallets were being stored in a way that prevented access to fire extinguishers and fire exits, and that a safety switch on a conveyor belt was not working because it was blocked with a cable tie.

He said that his activities resulted in a witch-hunt against him. He was given unpleasant jobs to do, was three times denied promotion and was insulted and harassed by way of the warehouse’s public radio channel. He resigned after his mental health deteriorated to the point where he dreaded going to work and had suicidal thoughts. He later launched ET proceedings.

In ruling on the matter, the ET found that he was constructively dismissed. He was badly treated on a number of occasions in a manner that amounted to a fundamental breach of the relationship of trust and confidence that should be a feature of any employment relationship. The mistreatment had caused his resignation.

He reasonably believed that his concerns were justified and that he had raised them in the public interest. Managers, however, ignored his disclosures and marked him down as a complainer. The various detriments to which he was subjected were connected to his whistleblowing activities and his dismissal was thus automatically unfair. His former employer was ordered to pay him £20,959 in compensation, including £6,000 for injury to his feelings.

Low Caste Hindu Refused Anonymity Order in Employment Case

The subject matter of Employment Tribunal (ET) cases can be highly sensitive, and those involved are often keen to maintain their anonymity. However, as was shown by a case in which controversial religious issues took centre stage, the open justice principle will usually require them to be identified by name. The case concerned a senior electrical engineer who was of Tamil origin and came from a low Hindu caste. In ET proceedings he asserted, amongst other things, that his line manager, a high…

Parcel Delivery Franchisees ‘Self-Employed’ – Guideline EAT Ruling

A right to substitute someone else to perform your work is perhaps the most powerful indicator that you are self-employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in finding that franchisees engaged by a parcel delivery company enjoyed neither the protected status of an employee nor that of a worker. The case concerned two men who entered into standard-form franchise agreements whereby they were required to provide a vehicle and driver to make collections and deliveries for the…

Workplace Disciplinary Proceedings – Empathy and Understanding Required

The critical issue in many employment cases is whether an employee’s dismissal lies within the range of reasonable responses open to the employer. As an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruling showed, the answer to that question often depends on the level of empathy and understanding shown in the disciplinary process. The case concerned a university library employee who was working alone behind the reception desk when, as she was entitled to do, she asked a student to show her photo identity…