Court of Appeal Upholds Entitlements of Employee on Long-Term Sick Leave

Many employers offer their staff the benefit of insurance-backed income protection schemes that provide them with financial security in the event of long-term illness. The legal effect of one such scheme came under analysis by the Court of Appeal in a case concerning an engineer who had been on…

Aug 09, 2022

Pexels cytonn photography 955389 1024x684

Many employers offer their staff the benefit of insurance-backed income protection schemes that provide them with financial security in the event of long-term illness. The legal effect of one such scheme came under analysis by the Court of Appeal in a case concerning an engineer who had been on sick leave for well over a decade.

The engineer went on sick leave in 2009, suffering from chronic fatigue syndrome, and had been off work continuously ever since. Throughout all but the first 13 weeks of his sick leave, he had claimed entitlements under his employer’s income protection scheme.

When he was taken on by the employer in 2003, his offer letter and the summary of benefits attached to it stated that, if he were off work sick for more than 13 weeks, the scheme would kick in and provide him with 75 per cent of his annual salary, less basic rate state long-term incapacity benefit, up to his 60th birthday.

Crucially, the documents also contained an escalator clause by which the benefits he received under the scheme would increase by 5 per cent annually in order to provide him with some degree of protection against inflation. After discovering some years later that the escalator clause had not been applied to his benefits under the scheme, he launched Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings.

The ET upheld his complaint that the failure to increase his benefits in line with the escalator clause amounted to an unlawful deduction from his wages. The decision, which was subsequently upheld by the Employment Appeal Tribunal, entitled him to compensation in respect of a two-year period prior to the date on which he lodged his claim. The ET was not empowered to make an award in respect of any longer period.

In its ruling, the ET found that the documents formed part of his employment contract and clearly set out his entitlements under the scheme. The employer’s plea that it had, prior to him going on sick leave, lawfully exercised its entitlement to unilaterally vary his contract by removing the benefit of the escalator clause was rejected. Its argument that its liabilities under the scheme were limited to the extent of its insurance cover also fell on fallow ground.

Dismissing the employer’s appeal against that outcome, the Court found that the entirely unambiguous documents were fit to be incorporated in his employment contract. There was nothing in his formal contract of employment that contradicted their terms. Even if the employer did have a contractual entitlement to unilaterally vary his contract, no such variation was communicated to him at the time.

The employer asserted that, given the low rates of inflation that had prevailed since he went on sick leave, the escalator clause was remarkably generous. Whether or not that was the case, however, the Court found that the clause represented what had been contractually agreed.

Not Every Accident Can be Explained – Workplace Head Injuries Ruling

Judges are experts at uncovering the truth but, in rare cases, it is simply not possible to decisively establish the cause of an accident. That was so in the case of an HGV driver who had no memory of an incident which left him with life-changing head injuries. The man had been cleaning his tractor unit before he was found unconscious in the yard of the crane hire company he worked for. Due to the severity of his head injuries, he had no recollection of how he suffered two blows with a hard,…

Knee-Jerk Dismissals Are No Way to Resolve Boardroom Conflicts

Boardroom tensions often lead to precipitate action but resorting to dismissal without following proper procedures is never a good solution. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in upholding whistleblowing, unfair dismissal and age discrimination complaints brought by a start-up company’s former chief financial officer. The woman’s dismissal occurred against a background of increasingly dysfunctional boardroom relationships. Without due process, she was removed as a Companies House…

The 2026 Legal Update: Employment Rights Act 2025 - What Every SME Needs to Know

The Employment Rights Act 2025 represents one of the most significant reforms to UK employment law in recent years. As key provisions come into force throughout 2026, employers should carefully review their existing practices to ensure alignment with the new statutory framework. These legislative changes introduce additional obligations for employers and enhanced protections for employees. For SMEs in particular, the practical and financial implications require early consideration and…