Veteran Supermarket Worker’s Summary Dismissal Did Not Fit the Offence

When dealing with allegations of gross misconduct, an employer may conduct an entirely reasonable investigation and disciplinary process, but as one case showed, the final – and perhaps most important – question in a decision-maker’s mind must be whether any sanction imposed fits the…

Jul 05, 2022

Person holds a basket full of groceries in a supermarket 1024x1024

When dealing with allegations of gross misconduct, an employer may conduct an entirely reasonable investigation and disciplinary process, but as one case showed, the final – and perhaps most important – question in a decision-maker’s mind must be whether any sanction imposed fits the offence.

The case concerned a bizarre series of text messages sent by a supermarket worker to his manager. They made reference to a knife and the manager viewed them as a threat. Following an internal investigation and disciplinary process, the worker was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct. He launched Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings, complaining of unfair and wrongful dismissal.

Ruling on the matter, the ET found that the investigatory and disciplinary procedure conducted by the employer was fair. It was entitled to find that the worker was guilty of serious misconduct and had displayed inappropriate behaviour that was capable of causing upset to his manager.

In upholding the worker’s claims, however, the ET noted that the messages were to a large extent nonsensical. They contained no explicit threat of harm and, in the absence of any evidence that they were intended to be threatening or intimidating, there was no basis for a finding of gross misconduct.

When deciding on the appropriate sanction, the employer was overly influenced by the manager’s strong reaction to the messages. The worker, who had 17 years of unblemished service behind him, swiftly acknowledged that he should not have sent them and apologised. Overall, the ET found that his summary dismissal fell outside the band of reasonable responses open to the employer.

The ET reduced the worker’s compensatory award by 25 per cent, and his basic award by 10 per cent, to take account of his own contributory fault. He had recklessly sent some stupid, random messages to his manager without thinking about how they might be received. Following those deductions, his total award came to £47,192.

Employment Tribunal Orders Unfairly Dismissed Railwayman’s Reinstatement

A finding of unfair dismissal will, in the vast majority of cases, straightforwardly result in an award of compensation. As one case showed, however, money is not always enough to make up for the destruction of a career and, in such cases, Employment Tribunals (ETs) also have the power to order reinstatement. The case concerned a veteran railwayman who joined a rail infrastructure company as an apprentice and worked his way up to the position of team leader. Given the risks involved in such…

Running a Business Via Group Chats and Instant Messaging Has Its Pitfalls

Business owners who use social media group chats or instant messaging as an easy means of communicating instructions to staff may be prompted by an Employment Tribunal (ET) decision to consider other management tools. The owner of a family-run plant nursery suffered from anxiety and, during a period in which he largely worked from home, communicated with staff by means of social media group chats. The tone of such messages was generally very informal and jokes and swear words were sometimes…

Furlough Whistleblower Succeeds in Automatic Unfair Dismissal Claim

Employees are entitled to insist that their employers abide by their legal obligations and should never be penalised for doing so. The point was made by the case of a woman who pointed out that a meeting with her boss had extended beyond her agreed working hours under the COVID-19 furlough scheme. The sales manager was on part-time flexible furlough during the pandemic and, on most days, her agreed working hours were between 10am and 4pm. During a performance review meeting with her boss, she…