Synthetic Football Pitch Triggers Information Rights Dispute

If you have environmental or health and safety concerns about a development in your area, you have a right to all the information you may need to mount a successful challenge. The First-tier Tribunal (FTT) made that point in a case concerning the controversial installation of a synthetic…

Aug 31, 2021

Fachry zella devandra yta zdp9pvm unsplash 1024x683

If you have environmental or health and safety concerns about a development in your area, you have a right to all the information you may need to mount a successful challenge. The First-tier Tribunal (FTT) made that point in a case concerning the controversial installation of a synthetic football pitch.

The rubber crumb pitch, made of thousands of end-of-life tyres, was close to homes, a primary school and a leisure centre. A local resident was concerned about the use of chemicals in the pitch’s maintenance and that the material used could result in pollution of the area with airborne nanoparticles. In exercising her right to information concerning the pitch, she posed 18 questions of the local authority.

The council’s initial response was that it did not hold the requested information. It later provided the resident with a maintenance manual for the pitch and answered one of her questions concerning a chemical used to prevent weed growth. The Information Commissioner subsequently rejected the resident’s complaint that the council’s response was inadequate.

The council said that it had worked with specialist consultants and the Football Foundation in selecting the most suitable material to use in the pitch’s construction. It asserted that it had carried out thorough searches of its email and digital records for further relevant information. However, its response contained no mention of paper records also having been searched.

In upholding the resident’s challenge to the Commissioner’s decision, the FTT noted that her right to information concerning the pitch was enshrined in the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 and the Freedom of Information Act 2000. The Commissioner was generally very critical of public authorities that failed to respond adequately to information requests.

On this occasion, however, the Commissioner failed to follow up on the council’s vague and general answers to the resident’s questions and accepted too easily that it held no further relevant information. Directing the council to reconsider its response, the FTT ruled that it had failed to show, on the balance of probabilities, that it did not hold the information requested. The FTT noted that, if the resident remained dissatisfied with the council’s fresh response, she would be able to make a further complaint to the Commissioner.

A Fair Redundancy Process Requires Consultation at a Formative Stage

A fair redundancy process requires consultation of affected employees at a formative stage when there is at least the potential for them to influence the outcome. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) succinctly made that point in finding that a recruitment consultant in the banking sector was unfairly dismissed. The man’s employer, part of an American-owned group, experienced a downturn in business due to the COVID-19 pandemic. A decision was taken that redundancies were required amongst…

What is a Detriment? EAT Ruling Clearly Sets Out the Correct Legal Test

The question of whether someone has suffered a ‘detriment’ is the central issue in a great many employment cases where discrimination or victimisation is alleged. In an important decision, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has given authoritative guidance on the correct legal test to be applied in such cases. When applying to become a police officer, a man at the outset disclosed to the force concerned that he was in the process of pursuing an employment claim against another force, alleging…

Knee-Jerk Dismissals Are No Way to Resolve Boardroom Conflicts

Boardroom tensions often lead to precipitate action but resorting to dismissal without following proper procedures is never a good solution. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in upholding whistleblowing, unfair dismissal and age discrimination complaints brought by a start-up company’s former chief financial officer. The woman’s dismissal occurred against a background of increasingly dysfunctional boardroom relationships. Without due process, she was removed as a Companies House…