Parcel Delivery Franchisees ‘Self-Employed’ – Guideline EAT Ruling

A right to substitute someone else to perform your work is perhaps the most powerful indicator that you are self-employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in finding that franchisees engaged by a parcel delivery company enjoyed neither the protected status of an employee nor…

Jan 14, 2022

Rosebox bfdscxmqvyc unsplash 819x1024

A right to substitute someone else to perform your work is perhaps the most powerful indicator that you are self-employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in finding that franchisees engaged by a parcel delivery company enjoyed neither the protected status of an employee nor that of a worker.

The case concerned two men who entered into standard-form franchise agreements whereby they were required to provide a vehicle and driver to make collections and deliveries for the company. They asserted that the agreements did not reflect the reality of the relationship and that they were in truth either employees or workers for the purposes of the Employment Rights Act 1996 or the Equality Act 2010.

In rejecting their arguments, however, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that the agreements reflected the true bargain that had been reached between them and the company. Pointing to their ability to substitute other drivers to perform their rounds, the ET found that the absence of an obligation personally to perform services for the company was inconsistent with either employee or worker status. The company’s argument that they were self-employed contractors prevailed.

Ruling on the men’s challenge to that outcome, the EAT noted that the agreements, amongst other things, required nominated drivers to be authorised by the company and to undergo appropriate training. Franchisees were personally liable for any breaches or non-compliance by nominated drivers with the agreements or the company’s operating manual. Nominated drivers were required to carry identity cards and to meet certain standards of dress, appearance and demeanour.

Dismissing the appeal, however, the EAT noted that the agreements did not require nominated drivers to be of a particular type or identity. There was no requirement that they come from the ranks of the company’s existing operatives. Subject to their fulfilment of certain generic minimum standards, the company was uninterested in their identity so long as their services were suitably performed.

Although the company exercised a not inconsiderable degree of control over the way in which its services were provided, the ET made no error in finding that, properly construed, the agreements did not require the men to perform their services personally. The genuine power of substitution enjoyed by franchisees was sufficiently unfettered to preclude both employee and worker status.

Employer Pays Price for ‘Abject’ Failures in Disciplinary Process

Dismissing an employee for misconduct without first engaging in a transparent and fair disciplinary process is the legal equivalent of holding a gun to your head. In a case on point, an Employment Tribunal (ET) did not mince words in publicly exposing an employer’s abject procedural failures. A gas engineer who had risen to a senior management role in the company for which he worked was summoned to a meeting on his return from a business trip. He was informed that a client had complained about…

COVID-19 Lockdowns No Excuse for Sub-Standard Redundancy Processes

The COVID-19 lockdowns plunged thousands of businesses into dire financial straits but, as an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, the unprecedented crisis in no way relieved hard-pressed employers of their legal obligation to manage redundancy processes openly and fairly. The case concerned a fitter/welder who was on furlough when made redundant by a small engineering company. The pandemic had a catastrophic impact on the company’s business – reducing its turnover from £11 million to £5…

Supreme Court Urges ‘Give and Take’ in Town or Village Green Dispute

Town or village greens (TVGs) are effectively sacrosanct against development and public access to them is heavily protected by law. However, they are often privately owned and, as an important Supreme Court ruling showed, that can create some stark conflicts of interest. The case concerned a 200-square-metre area on the quayside of a privately owned port. Entirely covered by concrete and long in use by HGVs and port vehicles, there was nothing bucolic about the site. The port’s owner erected a…