Marital Discrimination – ET Failed to Ask the Right Question

To treat employees unfavourably because they are married amounts, unsurprisingly, to unlawful discrimination. However, as one case showed, proving a causal link between such treatment and marital status can be highly demanding.

The case concerned a bookkeeper who was married…

Jan 20, 2023

Pexels the coach space 2977581 1024x683

To treat employees unfavourably because they are married amounts, unsurprisingly, to unlawful discrimination. However, as one case showed, proving a causal link between such treatment and marital status can be highly demanding.

The case concerned a bookkeeper who was married to the principal shareholder of the company for which she worked. After their relationship ended in acrimonious divorce, she was dismissed by the company’s managing director (MD). An Employment Tribunal (ET) subsequently upheld her complaint that the MD had discriminated against her because she was married.

In its decision, the ET found that the MD had sided with her husband in making false allegations against her and dismissing her on spurious grounds. She was wrongly accused of misusing the company’s IT system and, at one point, a wholly baseless complaint was made against her to the police. She was stripped of her directorship and was not paid dividends that were due to her.

In upholding the MD’s challenge to the ET’s ruling, however, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) found that the ET had failed properly to address the issue of whether it was her marital status that was the cause of her unfavourable treatment, as opposed to the fact that she was married to the shareholder.

The question was not whether she was badly treated because she was married to a particular person. The ET had failed to construct an appropriate comparator or to ask itself whether a hypothetical person in a close relationship with the shareholder, but not married to him, would have been treated any differently.

The EAT reached its conclusion with a heavy heart. The ET’s conclusion that she had been very badly treated by the MD, amongst others, could not be challenged. It had nevertheless failed to address its mind to the true issues in the case and its finding that the MD had subjected her to marital discrimination, contrary to Section 13(4) of the Equality Act 2010, could not stand.

High Court Delves into Social History to Resolve Widow’s Asbestos Claim

Many people are still being carried off by merciless cancer due to asbestos exposure in the dim and distant past. As a High Court ruling showed, it is the very passage of time that makes it so hard for their loved ones to obtain compensation. The case concerned a former plasterer who died, aged 72, from mesothelioma – an incurable form of cancer that commonly takes decades to develop and can be caused by breathing in a single asbestos fibre. His widow launched a personal injury claim against a…

Whistleblowing and the Need to Prove a Causal Link – Guideline Ruling

In order to succeed in a workplace whistleblowing claim, it is not enough merely to prove that you have made a protected disclosure. As one case showed, it is also necessary to establish a causal link between the disclosure and any detrimental treatment to which you have been subjected. The case involved a senior employee in a bank’s audit department. In a draft report, she expressed concerns about the bank’s risk exposure arising from a certain legal agreement. There was no dispute that she…

Wind Turbine Technician Due Compensation for Severed Left Arm

Even the most careful employees can suffer industrial accidents for which even the most safety-conscious employers can be held responsible. The High Court made that point in the case of a technician whose left arm was traumatically amputated whilst he worked on the inner machinery of an offshore wind turbine. The technician, whose reputation for carefulness had earned him the nickname ‘Mr Safety’, was working within the housing of the turbine, which was on board ship and being prepared for…