Whistleblowing Nurse’s Dismissal ‘Grossly Unfair’, Tribunal Rules

There are few things more serious in an employment context than sacking a whistleblower for performing a valuable public service. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in the case of a highly regarded nurse who was treated grossly unfairly for doing what she considered to be her…

Aug 19, 2021

Jeshoots com l0j0dhvwcie unsplash 1024x759

There are few things more serious in an employment context than sacking a whistleblower for performing a valuable public service. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in the case of a highly regarded nurse who was treated grossly unfairly for doing what she considered to be her duty.

The nurse had an unblemished employment record stretching to 38 years and had received commendations for her leadership skills, positivity and enthusiasm. On a number of occasions, she expressed concern to her NHS trust employer that her dedicated team of district nurses was being subjected to an excessive workload, resulting in an increasing number of absences due to stress and anxiety.

She bore responsibility for risk management and safeguarding issues and, following a patient’s death, informed her manager that she wished formally to instigate the trust’s whistleblowing procedure. She went on a brief period of leave soon afterwards and returned to find herself suspended. A disciplinary process followed, culminating in her dismissal.

After she launched proceedings, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found, amongst other things, that she had been automatically unfairly dismissed by reason of whistleblowing. The loss of her job was the grossly unfair result of a process, involving numerous people, that was designed to get rid of her because she had made protected disclosures in the public interest.

Rejecting the trust’s appeal against that ruling, the EAT noted that it was hard to see how the findings of the ET could have been more critical of the trust. An attempt had been made to beef up the case against her by suggesting that she had dishonestly handled charitable donations made by patients. There were no reasonable grounds for any such accusation and those responsible for her dismissal had no genuine belief that she had done anything wrong.

The ET had described in excruciating detail the manifest failings and fundamental unfairness of the trust in dealing with her suspension, the investigation into her conduct, her dismissal and the rejection of her internal appeal. It was therefore unsurprising that the trust had not challenged the ET’s further findings of wrongful dismissal and ordinary unfair dismissal.

The EAT found that the ET had given insufficient reasons when dealing with alleged incidents of whistleblowing detriment that preceded her dismissal. Those matters were sent back to the same ET for further consideration. In all other respects, the trust’s appeal was dismissed. The amount of compensation due to her would also be considered at a further hearing, if not agreed.

Social Worker’s Anxiety at Prospect of Attending Court Ruled a Disability

Activities that some people might find unconcerning can, for others, be a source of anxiety amounting to a full-blown disability. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in the case of a senior social worker who found the prospect of attending court hearings deeply disturbing. The woman, who dealt with many difficult matters involving children, had in the past attended a court hearing during which she was the subject of judicial criticism. She described the experience as traumatic.…

What is a Detriment? EAT Ruling Clearly Sets Out the Correct Legal Test

The question of whether someone has suffered a ‘detriment’ is the central issue in a great many employment cases where discrimination or victimisation is alleged. In an important decision, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has given authoritative guidance on the correct legal test to be applied in such cases. When applying to become a police officer, a man at the outset disclosed to the force concerned that he was in the process of pursuing an employment claim against another force, alleging…

Workplace Safety – Anxious Shop Worker Succeeds in Unfair Dismissal Claim

Aggressive customers are the bane of many shop workers’ lives and those workers are entitled to have their concerns for their safety at work fully addressed by their employers. An Employment Tribunal (ET) powerfully made that point in upholding a retail worker’s unfair dismissal complaint. The customer assistant had been on sick leave for several months, suffering from anxiety and depression, prior to her dismissal. She was concerned about the risk of infection with COVID-19 at work and said…