Inadequate Workplace Toilet Triggers Direct Sex Discrimination Finding

As those who follow the news will know, public and workplace toilet facilities are the focus of a national debate concerning gender. In an employment case on point, a female office clerk who had to share a toilet with male colleagues succeeded in a direct sex discrimination claim.

The…

Feb 15, 2023

Pexels tim mossholder 1722196 1024x683

As those who follow the news will know, public and workplace toilet facilities are the focus of a national debate concerning gender. In an employment case on point, a female office clerk who had to share a toilet with male colleagues succeeded in a direct sex discrimination claim.

The woman worked for a local authority in a building fitted with both male and female toilets. She used the female toilet when she could, but accessing it was problematic in that it was in part of the building used by a playgroup. In response, her employer offered her access to the male toilet, which consisted of a single cubicle that could only be entered by passing a trough urinal.

There was no lock on the entrance door to the male toilet. A sign was provided that alerted men when the toilet was occupied by a woman, but it did not always stay in place. There was in any event a risk that a man might disregard the sign. That in turn gave rise to a risk of women using the toilet witnessing a man at the urinal. During the relevant period, the toilet also did not feature a sanitary bin.

Upholding the woman’s sex discrimination complaint, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that she had been subjected to a series of detriments. The inadequate toilet facilities resulted in her being less favourably treated than her male colleagues. At no point was a man in a position of not having immediate access to a toilet and it did not matter whether the risk of her seeing a member of the opposite sex relieving himself had in fact materialised.

Rejecting the employer’s challenge to that decision, the Employment Appeal Tribunal noted that her difficulties could readily have been resolved by fitting a lock to the toilet’s entrance door and installing a sanitary bin. Both those steps were belatedly taken by the employer.

The ET had applied robust common sense in concluding that the toilet facilities were inherently discriminatory in that they did not adequately meet her needs as a woman. The risk of her coming across a man using the urinal and the lack of a sanitary bin both amounted to less favourable treatment arising from her gender.

In its ruling, the ET had also found that that she had been subjected to harassment on three occasions and had been victimised by being dismissed. The amount of her compensation would be assessed at a further hearing, if not agreed.

Employment Dispute Settlement Precludes Subsequent Victimisation Claim

The vast majority of employment cases end in compromise, thus doing away with the need for a public hearing. As a Court of Appeal ruling made plain, however, great professional care is required in drafting settlement agreements in order to ensure that they do not themselves become the focus of further dispute. The case concerned a man whose race discrimination complaint against a company for which he worked for about a month was compromised on confidential terms. He accepted a sum of money in…

Maternity Discrimination Victim Receives Substantial Compensation

Maternity leave should be a period of joy and tranquillity but, all too often, it is marred by discrimination. As an Employment Tribunal (ET) decision showed, however, employers who treat new mothers unfavourably can expect to pay a high reputational and financial price. The case concerned a group marketing director who was deeply upset by comments made by male colleagues after they heard of her pregnancy. One asked her when she had stopped taking contraception and how she thought having a…

Capability – Justifying the Dismissal of a Disabled Employee is Never Easy

Justifying the dismissal of a disabled employee on capability grounds is always likely to be an uphill struggle. That was certainly so in the case of an HGV driver who was sacked whilst in the midst of a long and painful recovery from major back surgery. The operation was serious enough to require the driver’s post-surgical treatment in a high dependency unit for three days. For months afterwards he required his wife’s help in climbing stairs and many of the most basic activities of daily life.…