Employment – The COVID-19 Chickens are Coming Home to Roost

Many businesses confronted by the existential crisis of the COVID-19 pandemic took swift steps to shed staff. However, as an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, the requirements of employment law were not suspended and, for those who failed to comply with them, the chickens are now coming…

Jul 19, 2022

Dose media gxgtqg5ul2g unsplash 1024x683

Many businesses confronted by the existential crisis of the COVID-19 pandemic took swift steps to shed staff. However, as an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, the requirements of employment law were not suspended and, for those who failed to comply with them, the chickens are now coming home to roost.

The case concerned a graphic designer who was made redundant a few days after the first lockdown came into force. His employer, a small company, experienced a precipitous decline in sales and, having decided not to partake in the furlough scheme, there was no dispute that it needed to cut staff numbers fast.

Ruling on the man’s unfair dismissal complaint, the ET acknowledged that a genuine redundancy situation had arisen, that the employer was facing a fast-moving and truly unprecedented crisis and that its resources were limited. It found, however, that the situation was not so exceptional as to permit the abandonment of proper redundancy procedures.

In upholding the claim, the ET noted that there was no consultation whatsoever prior to his selection for redundancy. He was given no real opportunity to challenge the decision before or after it was made and he received no explanation as to why he, rather than a colleague who performed a similar role, was being selected. His dismissal fell outside the band of reasonable responses open to an employer.

He was entitled to receive six weeks’ notice pay and a further three months’ pay in respect of accrued holiday allowance. However, the ET ruled that his compensatory award for unfair dismissal should be reduced by 60 per cent on the basis that, even had a fair procedure been followed, he would probably have lost his job. If not agreed, the amount of his award would be assessed at a further hearing.

You May Be Disabled in Common Parlance But Not in Law – Guideline Ruling

People have differing views as to what does or does not constitute a disability but, in employment law terms, the word has a very specific meaning. An Employment Tribunal (ET) succinctly made that point in finding that a workshop manager who suffered lower back pain and sciatica was not, in the legal sense, disabled. Following his dismissal by a design company, the man lodged proceedings with the ET complaining of, amongst other things, disability discrimination. The issue of whether his…

Workplace Banter May Be Fine, But Not If it Tips Over Into Harassment

A certain amount of foul-mouthed banter is only to be expected in a robust working environment. As an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, however, employers who allow it to tip over into hostile and discriminatory abuse are likely to pay a high financial and reputational price. The case concerned a white worker, aged in his early 50s, who was employed by a tyre recycling company. He worked as part of a small team in which white people were in a minority. He said that a younger black…

Nurse Victimised for Whistleblowing Receives Substantial Compensation

Workplace whistleblowing is an act of good citizenship and the law frowns deeply on employers who fail to respond appropriately. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in awarding substantial compensation to an NHS nurse who complained of racism and bullying on the ward where she worked. The nurse complained to her manager that junior colleagues were being bullied and that staff on the ward had formed into cliques, divided by race. She also asserted that racial factors were affecting the…