Decision-Maker’s Knowledge is Key in Whistleblowing Claim

Where an employee who has made a protected disclosure is dismissed, can the dismissal be unfair if the decision-maker is merely aware that the employee has made a disclosure, or is some understanding of the details of the disclosure required? That question was answered in an Employment Appeal…

Aug 01, 2024

Pexels cottonbro 7207354 683x1024

Where an employee who has made a protected disclosure is dismissed, can the dismissal be unfair if the decision-maker is merely aware that the employee has made a disclosure, or is some understanding of the details of the disclosure required? That question was answered in an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruling.

A man had raised various concerns relating to the management style of his employer’s CEO. A meeting took place in which he claimed that issues raised in another employee’s exit interview were discussed. He sent an email stating that this was inappropriate and amounted to bullying and harassment in respect of the employee concerned. His email might have been forwarded to the CEO but was not read by her.

After he was dismissed, purportedly on redundancy grounds, he brought an Employment Tribunal (ET) claim, alleging that he had been unfairly dismissed and subjected to detriment as a result of making protected disclosures, contrary to Sections 103A and 47B of the Employment Rights Act 1996.

The ET found that there was no genuine redundancy, and that the redundancy label was a cover for the breakdown in relations that had occurred between him and his employer. The decision to dismiss him had been made by the CEO. The contents of his email amounted to a protected disclosure but were not communicated to the CEO in sufficient detail to make her aware that a protected disclosure had been made. Dismissing his claim, the ET concluded that the employer had not considered him to be a whistleblower and he had neither been dismissed nor suffered detriment for making disclosures.

He appealed to the EAT, arguing that, having found that the information in his email constituted a protected disclosure and that his concerns had been communicated to the CEO, the ET had been wrong to impose an additional test in considering whether she had sufficient knowledge of the disclosures. He contended that it was only necessary that she be aware of the disclosures. He also claimed that whether the employer believed him to be a whistleblower was irrelevant to the analysis the ET should have carried out.

The EAT concluded that, for employers to be liable, it is necessary for them to know at least something of the employee’s concerns. The ET had not erred in law by considering what details of the man’s disclosures had been provided to the CEO. The ET was also entitled to consider whether the man was regarded as a whistleblower and whether this had any impact on the employer’s decision. The ET had answered the correct question: namely, whether he was dismissed for making disclosures. Although other grounds of his appeal succeeded, these did not affect the overall outcome.

Parcel Delivery Franchisees ‘Self-Employed’ – Guideline EAT Ruling

A right to substitute someone else to perform your work is perhaps the most powerful indicator that you are self-employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in finding that franchisees engaged by a parcel delivery company enjoyed neither the protected status of an employee nor that of a worker. The case concerned two men who entered into standard-form franchise agreements whereby they were required to provide a vehicle and driver to make collections and deliveries for the…

Workplace Banter May Be Fine, But Not If it Tips Over Into Harassment

A certain amount of foul-mouthed banter is only to be expected in a robust working environment. As an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, however, employers who allow it to tip over into hostile and discriminatory abuse are likely to pay a high financial and reputational price. The case concerned a white worker, aged in his early 50s, who was employed by a tyre recycling company. He worked as part of a small team in which white people were in a minority. He said that a younger black…

Time Limits in Employment Cases – Any Delay Could Stymie Your Claim

Time limits are strictly applied in employment cases and any failure to abide by them can place even an otherwise meritorious claim in real jeopardy. That was certainly so in the case of a call centre worker who lodged a sexual harassment complaint a single day later than she should have done. Following a hearing, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that the woman had, on three separate occasions, been sexually harassed by her line manager. He had, amongst other things, pulled her waist during a…