EAT Reinstates Claims Struck Out for Failure to Comply With Order

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has upheld an appeal against the striking out of a man’s claims after he failed to comply with a case management order, finding that the Employment Tribunal (ET) had failed to consider whether a fair trial was still possible and that an unless order should…

Jul 30, 2025

Balance scale tilted right 1024x683

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has upheld an appeal against the striking out of a man’s claims after he failed to comply with a case management order, finding that the Employment Tribunal (ET) had failed to consider whether a fair trial was still possible and that an unless order should have been made instead.

The man had brought a number of claims including disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment and victimisation. The ET considered that it was not possible to work out from the particulars of claim the precise allegations he wished to pursue and ordered him to respond to a list of issues compiled by the employer.

After he failed to so do, the employer applied to strike out his claims. Concluding that the claims should be struck out, the ET found that there had been a ‘persistent and deliberate’ delay by the man, and observed that he had been warned that strike out was likely if he failed to comply with the order.

The man appealed to the EAT, claiming that the ET had applied the wrong legal test to the question of strike out, had failed to ask itself whether a fair hearing was still possible and had not taken sufficient account of his status as a litigant in person and a disabled person.

The EAT noted that the ET had not at any stage considered whether it was possible to have a fair trial. The ET had stated that, for a claim to be struck out, either there needed to be a deliberate and persistent disregard of required procedural steps or a fair trial must be impossible. The ET seemed to have regarded these reasons as alternatives, and had based its decision on the former without looking at the impact of the latter. This was an error of law.

The EAT did not think the ET had been right to strike out the claims without first making an unless order. It noted that if an unless order had not been complied with, the claims would have been struck out automatically. If it had been, a fair trial was certainly possible. The fact that the man had since filed the required response demonstrated that there should have been much greater optimism on the ET’s part about the possible effect of an unless order in securing compliance. The EAT considered that it was hard to think of a case in which it would be right to go directly from non-compliance to striking out without first making an unless order. The EAT concluded that the appeal must be allowed.

Workplace Drugs Policies – ET Fell into Substitution Trap

When considering whether a dismissal is unfair, Employment Tribunals (ETs) must resist the temptation to substitute their own views for those of the employer. That golden rule came under analysis in a case concerning a worker who was dismissed after testing positive for cannabis. The man, a team leader who worked for a recycling company, had been off work for an extended period, suffering from back pain. He self-medicated with cannabis and failed a random drug test after his return to work. He…

The Law is Not in the Business of Discouraging High-Risk Adventure Sports

Adventure sports enthusiasts have a perfect right voluntarily to place themselves in danger and, as a High Court ruling showed, the law is not in the business of discouraging organisers of challenging and high-risk events. The case concerned a very fit middle-aged woman who took part in a demanding obstacle race. She was swinging between monkey rings when she fell to the ground, suffering serious injuries to her right leg and shoulder. She sought compensation from the event’s organisers on the…

Asbestos Case Focuses on Chemistry Lab Heat Mats Phased Out 50 Years Ago

Anyone who worked in a chemistry lab or who was at school more than 50 years ago is likely to remember the ubiquitous asbestos mats on which Bunsen burners rested. In a sad case that vividly evoked the past, the High Court considered whether their presence can give rise to employer liability in the 21st century. The case concerned a man who worked as an NHS hospital lab technician between 1949 and 1960. He was 86 in 2019 when he was diagnosed with mesothelioma, a form of lung cancer almost…