You May Be Disabled in Common Parlance But Not in Law – Guideline Ruling

People have differing views as to what does or does not constitute a disability but, in employment law terms, the word has a very specific meaning. An Employment Tribunal (ET) succinctly made that point in finding that a workshop manager who suffered lower back pain and sciatica was not, in the…

Feb 28, 2022

Pexels olga petrova 11093276 819x1024

People have differing views as to what does or does not constitute a disability but, in employment law terms, the word has a very specific meaning. An Employment Tribunal (ET) succinctly made that point in finding that a workshop manager who suffered lower back pain and sciatica was not, in the legal sense, disabled.

Following his dismissal by a design company, the man lodged proceedings with the ET complaining of, amongst other things, disability discrimination. The issue of whether his condition met the legal definition of a disability, within the meaning of Section 6 of the Equality Act 2010, was considered as a preliminary issue.

Ruling on the matter, the ET noted that his work involved some physical exertion and required him to walk several miles a day. During the period prior to his dismissal, his back condition amounted to a physical impairment that caused him pain whilst performing day-to-day activities. He took prescribed painkillers and suffered particular discomfort during flare-ups of his condition.

On the other hand, the ET observed that his lifestyle was at the time an active one. He liked to go on annual snowboarding trips abroad and, at home, enjoyed rearing birds for their eggs and engaging in substantial DIY projects. On the evidence, the ET was not satisfied that his pain was constant or that it caused him difficulty in sleeping, using the toilet at work or brushing his teeth.

The ET emphasised that the fact that someone can only carry out normal day-to-day activities with pain does not establish that they are disabled in the statutory sense. It found that the man’s physical impairment during the relevant period did not have a substantial adverse effect on his ability to carry out such activities. As he had failed to establish that he was disabled, his discrimination claim failed.

Hotel Owner Ruled Liable Following Guest’s Fatal Fall from Window

Property occupiers are obliged to take reasonable care for the safety of their visitors, but does that duty extend to those who choose to take obvious risks? The Court of Appeal addressed that issue in a guideline case concerning a hotel guest who fell out of a window to his death. The man was staying on the hotel’s second floor after attending a wedding when he fell nine metres from the sash window in the early hours of the morning. His widow sought compensation from the hotel’s owner under…

Nurse Receives £41,000 Compensation for Constructive Dismissal

A nurse who was subjected to bullying behaviour by a colleague has succeeded in her claim of constructive unfair dismissal against the NHS trust she worked for. The nurse had begun working for the trust as a Diabetes Specialist Nurse in 2012. In September 2018, she disagreed with a colleague about the appropriate treatment of a patient, and he asked if she was questioning his competency. After she reported the incident it was confirmed that her clinical assessment had been correct. She claimed…

Plagued by Former Employees Turned Competitors? See a Lawyer Today!

Many business owners lie awake at night worrying that senior employees may leave to set up rival operations, taking clients and confidential information with them. Such conduct is, however, highly likely to be unlawful and, as one case showed, specialist lawyers can very swiftly take steps to nip it in the bud. The case concerned a share purchase agreement (SPA), by which a consultancy group acquired the entire issued share capital of a rival company for over £6.4 million. As part of the deal,…