University Manager Succeeds in Unfair Dismissal/Disability Discrimination Claims

Redundancy processes that lack transparency or fail to pay particular regard to the position of disabled employees are highly likely to result in costly Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings. That was certainly so in the case of a university faculty manager who lost her job in the midst of a…

Nov 03, 2023

Lisbon university building with glass windows 683x1024

Redundancy processes that lack transparency or fail to pay particular regard to the position of disabled employees are highly likely to result in costly Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings. That was certainly so in the case of a university faculty manager who lost her job in the midst of a restructuring exercise.

The woman suffered from depression and general anxiety disorder and was agreed to be disabled. With a view to cutting costs and achieving greater efficiency, the university decided to merge her faculty with another. She and a number of other managers were informed that they were at risk of redundancy.

She had the opportunity to apply for two alternative positions in the new structure but was on sick leave at the relevant time and not well enough to attend interviews. She was dismissed on grounds of redundancy after failing to obtain either of those positions. She subsequently launched ET proceedings.

Ruling on the matter, the ET found that a genuine redundancy situation had arisen and that the university’s approach to it was, in broad terms, reasonable. There was a potentially fair reason for her dismissal. It was not inherently unfair to have regard to her state of health when considering whether she was likely to be fit enough to take up one of the alternative positions within a reasonable period.

In nevertheless upholding her unfair dismissal claim, the ET noted that the selection process was presented to her as an assessment of her skills and knowledge. At no stage was it suggested to her that the university might believe that her health issues precluded her appointment. She was given no chance to respond to such concerns, and occupational health reports which indicated that she would be capable of a phased return to work within a few months were not taken into account.

The ET rejected the university’s plea that her dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. Her dismissal was also discriminatory in that it was unfavourable treatment because of something arising in consequence of her disability. Her compensation, if not agreed, would be assessed at a further hearing on the basis that she lost a one-in-three chance of being appointed to one of the alternative posts and a one-in-two chance of appointment to the other.

Taking On Staff? Doing So Prematurely Can Have Serious Consequences

Taking on staff is often a necessary precursor to setting up a new business. As an Employment Tribunal (ET) decision showed, however, entering into any form of binding employment relationship is a serious step and doing so prematurely can have grave financial consequences. The case concerned an entrepreneur who set up a security company with a view to providing lucrative services to a high net worth individual who intended to visit the UK. Two days after its incorporation, the company entered…

‘Secular Atheism’ a Philosophical Belief Worthy of Human Rights Protection

It is a fundamental feature of any democratic society that anyone can freely express their philosophical beliefs, even if others may find them offensive. An Employment Tribunal (ET) powerfully made that point in the case of a train conductor who was sacked after venting his secular atheist views on social media. In welcoming the reopening of pubs at the end of a COVID-19 lockdown, the man wrote an online post urging people not to let their way of life ‘become some sort of Muslim alcohol-free…

Workplace Harassment Can Be Downright Cruel – You Don’t Have to Take It

Harassment in the workplace can descend into downright cruelty and employers who fail to stamp out such behaviour can expect to pay a heavy reputational and financial price. In a case on point, a sandwich shop worker who endured her line manager’s wounding comments received substantial compensation. The woman, who was in her probationary period at the shop, was being treated for a number of medical conditions, which amounted to a disability. Her numerous allergies required her to carry an…