No Transfer of Vicarious Liability Under TUPE, High Court Rules

When a transfer of a business takes place to which the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (TUPE) applies, does any vicarious liability of the original…

Jun 10, 2025

Pexels pixabay 236380 1024x678

When a transfer of a business takes place to which the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (TUPE) applies, does any vicarious liability of the original employer to a third party for wrongdoing by an employee transfer to the new employer? The High Court has answered that question with a resounding ‘no’.

A woman was seeking damages for wrongs suffered while she had been a hospital inpatient. She claimed that the company that had owned the hospital was responsible for wrongs committed by two of its employees. The company had subsequently sold its business, and it was accepted that TUPE applied to the transfer. The Court considered as preliminary issues whether the effect of Regulation 4(2) of TUPE – under which the transferor’s ‘rights, powers, duties and liabilities under or in connection with’ contracts of employment transfer to the transferee – was to transfer any vicarious liability of the company for torts and/or breaches of human rights by its employees to the new employer.

The Court noted that domestic courts are under an obligation to interpret legislation, so far as possible, in the light of the wording and purpose of the Directive it seeks to implement. The purpose of the Transfers of Undertakings Directive, which TUPE implements into UK law, is to safeguard employee rights after a transfer of employment.

The question before the Court could effectively be expressed as whether the connection between the relevant liability and the employment contracts was sufficient to bring the liability within Regulation 4(2) so that it transferred to the new employer. The Court observed that there were no cases decided at High Court level or above where vicarious liability of the type at issue had been found to have transferred under TUPE.

In the Court’s judgment, previous cases showed that the connection between the liability of a transferor and the contract must be direct, in the sense of being a liability the transferor has to an employee, if the liability is to transfer. The cases described liabilities that are sufficiently closely connected to the contract as fundamental parts of the relationship between employer and employee. If the company had any liability, it was not owed to its employees: the relevant direct liability was the employees’ liability to the woman. The connection between the liability and the employment contracts was therefore too remote and the liability did not transfer under Regulation 4(2).

Suspension on Award of Fire Brigade Safety Equipment Contract Maintained

If you feel that you have been treated unfairly in a public contract tendering exercise, you are anything but powerless and should take legal advice straight away. A High Court case on point concerned the award of a contract for the supply of protective breathing equipment to a municipal fire brigade. Recent years have brought significant improvements in safety apparatus used by firefighters and, against the background of the Grenfell Tower disaster, the brigade was anxious to update its…

HSE Encourages Employers to Tackle Workplace Stress

As part of its Working Minds campaign, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has called on employers to support workers’ mental health during Stress Awareness Month. Employers are encouraged to focus on one of the campaign’s five Rs for each week of April. These are:Reach out and have conversations; Recognise the signs and causes of stress; Respond to any risks you have identified; Reflect on actions you have agreed and taken; and Make it Routine.Employers are legally required to prevent…

Postman Sacked Following Flawed Investigation Wins Unfair Dismissal Claim

A finding of dishonesty against an employee is a grave matter that is highly likely to negatively impact on their future working life. In upholding a postman’s unfair dismissal claim, an Employment Tribunal (ET) emphasised that such a finding can only be justified following a thorough and reasonable investigation. The postman was accused of stealing a letter from a bank that had been left sticking out of a householder’s letterbox. The evidence against him included CCTV footage from a video…