Tribunal Condemns ‘Inept and Misjudged’ Workplace Bullying Investigation

Employers who fail to conduct workplace disciplinary proceedings fairly risk serious financial and reputational consequences. In one case, a company’s handling of a bullying investigation was roundly condemned as a catalogue of ineptitude and misjudgment.

The case concerned a business…

Aug 11, 2021

Pexels cowomen 2041629 1024x683

Employers who fail to conduct workplace disciplinary proceedings fairly risk serious financial and reputational consequences. In one case, a company’s handling of a bullying investigation was roundly condemned as a catalogue of ineptitude and misjudgment.

The case concerned a business development manager who was accused of bullying a subordinate. Whilst accepting that she could sometimes be abrupt, she denied that she was a bully or that she had any intention to cause distress. She was dismissed following a lengthy investigatory and disciplinary process.

After she launched proceedings, an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruled that her summary dismissal, without notice, was wrongful. The evidence was entirely consistent with her inadvertently having caused stress to the subordinate. Given the lack of any proof of malign intent on her part, her conduct did not meet the employer’s policy definition of bullying and thus did not amount to gross misconduct.

The ET made numerous criticisms of the conduct of the investigatory and disciplinary process. In rejecting her unfair dismissal claim, however, it found that the decision-maker genuinely believed that she had behaved inappropriately. The ET was just persuaded that it fell within the band of reasonable responses for the company to consider that the process was, in the circumstances, adequate.

Upholding her challenge to that ruling, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) found that it was one of those rare cases where an ET had reached a perverse conclusion. Given the catalogue of failings identified, there was no basis on which a reasonable ET could find that the process fell within a reasonable band. Subject to any submissions to the contrary, the EAT ruled that the unfair dismissal claim should be remitted to the same ET for reconsideration.

Houses in Multiple Occupation – A Cautionary Tale for Errant Landlords

Pressure on the housing market has led to the conversion of many redundant office buildings into flats and the number of such projects is likely to be greatly increased by shifting work patterns brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic. A Court of Appeal ruling, however, powerfully signalled that rules in respect of health, safety and living standards at such premises will be rigorously enforced. The case concerned an office block that had been converted into 47 flats. After a housing officer…

High Court Apportions Liability for Worker’s Construction Site Fall

Construction workers often do not have formal employment contracts and, in a world where contractors and subcontractors proliferate, it can be hard to tell where legal responsibility lies in the event of an accident. That was certainly so in a High Court case concerning a labourer who suffered catastrophic injuries in a workplace fall. The worker was engaged in building a mezzanine office at factory premises when he fell onto concrete, fracturing his skull. He suffered a severe brain injury,…

Pregnancy ‘Played a Part’ in Redundancy Decision – Discrimination Ruling

Maternity leave is every expectant mother’s entitlement and, if you feel that you have suffered pregnancy discrimination, you should contact a solicitor without delay. The point was powerfully made by the case of a woman whose pregnancy played a part in her employer’s decision to make her redundant. Having twice become pregnant, the woman took successive periods of maternity leave which together lasted over two years. Not long after returning to work, she became pregnant for a third time and…