Locum Consultant Not Entitled to Permanent Contract

Under Regulation 8 of the Fixed-term Employees (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2002, employees who have worked continuously for four years or more under a series…

Aug 29, 2024

Doctor reaches towards shelf 1024x683

Under Regulation 8 of the Fixed-term Employees (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2002, employees who have worked continuously for four years or more under a series of fixed-term contracts automatically become permanent employees unless the renewal of their employment on a fixed-term contract was objectively justified. Recently, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) considered whether such justification applied in the case of a locum consultant.

The consultant was employed by an NHS trust as a locum consultant breast surgeon. She applied to the Employment Tribunal (ET) for a declaration under Regulation 9(5) of the Regulations that she had become a permanent employee. The trust contested her application. The other conditions having been met, the ET had to consider whether her continued employment under a fixed-term contract was objectively justified.

Concluding that it was, the ET noted that one of the purposes of the Regulations is to guard against the abuse of fixed-term contracts. The trust contended that it had the legitimate aim of providing a safe, efficient and fully functioning Breast Service. Following a service review, the trust had identified a need to appoint a permanent consultant breast surgeon and it was appropriate to use a fixed-term contract for a locum consultant to secure the provision of services pending the appointment. There were key differences between her role and the permanent consultant role. The use of a fixed-term contract was neither abusive nor discriminatory. The ET also rejected her claim that the trust had not acted in good faith. She appealed to the EAT.

The EAT found that there was no error of law in the ET’s approach to the question of whether her continued employment on a fixed-term contract was objectively justified. The ET’s finding that the locum and permanent consultant roles were genuinely different also contained no error of law and was open to it on the facts. The ET had also provided more than sufficient reasoning for its decision that the trust had not demonstrated a lack of good faith, and that decision was not perverse. The appeal was dismissed.

Health and Safety – Spa Hotel Appeals Against Legionella Bans

It is hard to imagine circumstances that might outweigh the imperative of maintaining public health and safety. The point was made by the case of a spa hotel which had its pools and hot tubs placed off limits after a former guest was admitted to hospital suffering from Legionnaires’ disease. After the man was taken ill, the hotel’s manager agreed voluntarily to prohibit use of its showers, indoor hot tub and indoor swimming pool until water sample results were received. Public Health England…

Parcel Delivery Franchisees ‘Self-Employed’ – Guideline EAT Ruling

A right to substitute someone else to perform your work is perhaps the most powerful indicator that you are self-employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in finding that franchisees engaged by a parcel delivery company enjoyed neither the protected status of an employee nor that of a worker. The case concerned two men who entered into standard-form franchise agreements whereby they were required to provide a vehicle and driver to make collections and deliveries for the…

Asbestos Case Focuses on Chemistry Lab Heat Mats Phased Out 50 Years Ago

Anyone who worked in a chemistry lab or who was at school more than 50 years ago is likely to remember the ubiquitous asbestos mats on which Bunsen burners rested. In a sad case that vividly evoked the past, the High Court considered whether their presence can give rise to employer liability in the 21st century. The case concerned a man who worked as an NHS hospital lab technician between 1949 and 1960. He was 86 in 2019 when he was diagnosed with mesothelioma, a form of lung cancer almost…