Can a Sham Procedure Comply With the Acas Code? Employment Test Case

Responsible employers who follow full and fair procedures in line with the Acas Code generally have a powerful defence to unfair dismissal claims – but what if a procedure is found to be a total sham? The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) considered that issue in an important test…

Jun 27, 2022

Pexels antoni shkraba 4348404 1024x695

Responsible employers who follow full and fair procedures in line with the Acas Code generally have a powerful defence to unfair dismissal claims – but what if a procedure is found to be a total sham? The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) considered that issue in an important test case.

The case concerned a senior employee who was purportedly dismissed on grounds of redundancy. In upholding her subsequent unfair dismissal claim, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that the redundancy procedure was a total sham. Its outcome was a foregone conclusion in that the decision to dismiss her had been taken long before. The ET went on to find that her employer had breached the Code and that her compensation should for that reason be uplifted by the maximum permissible 25 per cent.

In challenging the latter decision, the employer contended that the Code had no application to the case. It pointed out that the Code only applies to disciplinary or grievance situations and that its focus is on ensuring employer compliance with basic procedural requirements rather than substantive fairness.

Dismissing the appeal, however, the EAT found that the applicability of the Code is a matter of substance rather than form. It did not consider that an employer could sidestep application of the Code by dressing up a dismissal for misconduct or poor performance by pretending that it is for some other reason, such as redundancy.

If an employer seeks to employ a procedure that fully complies with the Acas Code, but makes such a mess of it that the dismissal is unfair, the EAT could see that it might not be appropriate to award an uplift. However, if an employer acts in bad faith and pretends to apply an appropriate procedure, the EAT could not see how that could amount to compliance with the Code.

On a fair reading of the ET’s decision, it must have concluded that the employer had taken against the employee and that its dissatisfaction with her should have been dealt with under a capability or disciplinary procedure. Given that her dismissal was predetermined and nothing she said could have made any difference, there was a complete failure to apply any of the protections provided for by the Code.

Acas Updates Code of Practice on Flexible Working

Following recent changes to the law and a consultation last year, the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas) has updated its statutory Code of Practice on requests for flexible working, replacing the previous version published in June 2014. From 6 April, employees have a right to request to work flexibly from the first day of their employment. Previously, employees only had this right once they had worked for their employer for at least 26 weeks. The updated Code encourages…

Work Relationships May Be Informal But Employment is Employment

When you engage someone to work in the informal sanctum of your own home, it is easy to forget that you are very likely to owe them all the legal duties of an employer. An Employment Tribunal (ET) powerfully made that point in upholding a home carer’s unfair dismissal complaint. The carer was employed by a mother to look after her son, who had round-the-clock care needs. His role demanded the utmost trustworthiness and reliability. He formed a close bond with his charge and, although the…

Victim of Anti-English Workplace Abuse Receives Substantial Damages

A certain amount of workplace banter may be tolerated, but every sensible employer is aware that it may be the thin end of a wedge leading to unlawful discrimination. In a case on point, an English lorry driver who suffered wounding verbal abuse after taking a job north of the border was awarded substantial compensation. The man’s line manager did not like him and referred to him in demeaning and foul-mouthed terms by reference to his nationality. During a football tournament, he was informed…