Knee-Jerk Dismissals Are No Way to Resolve Boardroom Conflicts

Boardroom tensions often lead to precipitate action but resorting to dismissal without following proper procedures is never a good solution. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in upholding whistleblowing, unfair dismissal and age discrimination complaints brought by a start-up company’s…

Sep 01, 2022

Boardroom meeting flatlay 1024x683

Boardroom tensions often lead to precipitate action but resorting to dismissal without following proper procedures is never a good solution. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in upholding whistleblowing, unfair dismissal and age discrimination complaints brought by a start-up company’s former chief financial officer.

The woman’s dismissal occurred against a background of increasingly dysfunctional boardroom relationships. Without due process, she was removed as a Companies House director whilst she was on annual leave and the decision to terminate her employment was taken whilst she was off sick, suffering from stress.

The company asserted that it had no option but to dismiss her under pressure from its investors, who were unhappy with her performance. In upholding her automatic unfair dismissal complaint, however, the ET found that the principal reason for her dismissal was her whistleblowing activities.

She had made protected disclosures concerning various matters, including corporate governance and the treatment of a colleague whom she believed to be on the verge of a breakdown. As a result, she had been subjected to detriments, including her removal as a director and her placement on gardening leave.

Her request for an extraordinary general meeting to discuss her grievances was rejected as frivolous, defamatory and vexatious and, shortly before her dismissal, documentation was issued with a view to raising further investment that made no reference to her role as the company’s CFO and one of its founders.

Her claim of ordinary unfair dismissal was also well founded in that the decision to dismiss her was taken before she was invited to any meeting. She was subjected to a disciplinary process without being given an opportunity to respond to any allegations against her during an investigatory stage.

In also upholding her age discrimination complaint, the ET found that at least part of the reason for her dismissal was her age, which was 55 at the time. At one meeting, one of her fellow directors had told her to ‘calm down…don’t let the hormones get out of control’. That was evidence that he regarded her as a menopausal woman who was not familiar with the company’s IT business.

The ET acknowledged that the company and its investors did have some substantial concerns about her performance. Although that was not the reason for her dismissal, it found that there was a 30 per cent chance that she would have been dismissed in any event on capability grounds. The amount of her compensation, which would be assessed at a further hearing if not agreed, would be reduced by that percentage accordingly.

Pressurised Delivery Driver Succeeds in Disability Discrimination Claim

The pressure under which the UK’s legion of delivery drivers work is well known. As an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, however, workers’ disabilities must never be ignored when assigning them a reasonable workload. A delivery driver who was disabled by learning difficulties, severe hearing impairment and dysarthria, a speech disorder, was dismissed following a report that he had been filmed throwing delivery boxes from the back of his lorry. On the day of the incident, he had been…

Employed or Self-Employed? The Issue Can Present a Moving Target

The question of whether an individual is an employee or self-employed is highly fact sensitive and can, over time, present a moving target. That was certainly so in the case of a car body paintwork sprayer who, after setting up in business on his own account, eventually came to have only one customer. The man was the sole proprietor of a business that initially had three customers. He at first performed work for a vehicle sales company on three days a week, leaving time for him to serve his…

Grocery Supplier Fined After Worker Killed by Reversing HGV

A grocery wholesaler has been prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and fined £1 million following an accident in which a worker was killed by a reversing HGV. The man and a colleague were making a delivery to a store when the accident happened. He was acting as a banksman while his colleague was reversing the HGV into the store’s unloading area. He became trapped between the HGV and a wall, sustaining fatal crush injuries. An investigation by the HSE found that the wholesaler had…