Dismissal of a Disabled Employee is Tough to Justify

It is possible objectively to justify an employee’s dismissal for reasons related to his or her disability. However, as a case concerning an autistic university analyst made plain, establishing such a justification is, to say the least, a demanding task.

The man, who had been diagnosed…

Dec 02, 2021

Students head to class 683x1024

It is possible objectively to justify an employee’s dismissal for reasons related to his or her disability. However, as a case concerning an autistic university analyst made plain, establishing such a justification is, to say the least, a demanding task.

The man, who had been diagnosed with high-functioning autism, was on long-term sick leave, suffering from stress, when he was dismissed. After he lodged a disability discrimination claim with an Employment Tribunal (ET), the university accepted that his dismissal was for reasons related to his disability and that this was unfavourable treatment.

In rejecting his complaint, however, the ET found that his dismissal was objectively justified as a proportionate means of achieving the legitimate aim of ensuring the efficient running of the department in which he worked, as part of the overall provision of services to students.

The ET found that the university had been extremely accommodating in seeking to ensure his ability to participate in the lengthy, four-stage process that preceded his dismissal. It had gone above and beyond what was reasonably required. It had sought advice from occupational health professionals and paid for a specialist assessment by a consultant psychiatrist.

Although the burden of establishing an objective justification rested on the university, the ET noted that there had to be a timescale in relation to his return to work. It was obvious that holding his job open for him indefinitely would be significantly disruptive to the university.

Upholding his challenge to that outcome, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) noted that the ET was required to carry out its own critical evaluation of the evidence, weighing in the balance the needs of the employer against the discriminatory impact of his dismissal. It was not enough for the ET to ask itself whether dismissal fell within the band of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer.

The ET did not explain its conclusion that it would be obviously disruptive to hold his job open for him any longer. It made no findings as to whether his role was satisfactorily covered during his absence or whether there was any additional cost to the university. On the facts of the case, a disruptive impact was not immediately apparent. The EAT could not be satisfied from the reasons given by the ET that its conclusion that the dismissal was a proportionate measure was safe. The man’s case was remitted to the same ET for fresh consideration.

Highway Authority Not Responsible for Catastrophic M25 Lorry Crash

Those involved in catastrophic road accidents frequently point the finger of blame at potholes or other defects in the road surface. As one case showed, however, it can be an uphill task to pin responsibility for such accidents on highway authorities. The case concerned an accident which befell an articulated lorry whilst works were in progress to convert a stretch of the M25 into a smart motorway. The lorry was using the hard shoulder when its wheels strayed onto the verge and over a filter…

Employment Dispute Settlement Precludes Subsequent Victimisation Claim

The vast majority of employment cases end in compromise, thus doing away with the need for a public hearing. As a Court of Appeal ruling made plain, however, great professional care is required in drafting settlement agreements in order to ensure that they do not themselves become the focus of further dispute. The case concerned a man whose race discrimination complaint against a company for which he worked for about a month was compromised on confidential terms. He accepted a sum of money in…

Whistleblowing and the Importance of Causation – Guideline EAT Ruling

To succeed in a whistleblowing claim it is necessary to show not only that there has been a protected disclosure and a detrimental act but also that there is a causal link between the two. As an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruling made plain, that last element is in many cases the hardest to establish. In upholding a teacher’s whistleblowing claim, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that she had made protected disclosures about practices within the nursery school where she worked. It also…