COVID-19 – Carer Sacked After Visiting Pub Wins Unfair Dismissal Claim

The pressure put on many employment relationships by COVID-19 was illustrated by the case of a care worker who was sacked by her vulnerable charge’s mother after she went to the pub in the very early stages of the pandemic.

The carer was one of a team employed by the mother to look after…

Jun 21, 2021

Dovi rfofrwkhtjm unsplash 1024x683

The pressure put on many employment relationships by COVID-19 was illustrated by the case of a care worker who was sacked by her vulnerable charge’s mother after she went to the pub in the very early stages of the pandemic.

The carer was one of a team employed by the mother to look after her daughter, who suffers from cerebral palsy and is particularly susceptible to infection. On Friday, 20 March 2020, she went to the pub with her partner and a friend. At almost exactly the same time, the Prime Minister addressed the nation and urged people to avoid pubs, bars, clubs and restaurants. Lockdown was imposed three days later.

After the carer had been on furlough for some months, she was suspended on the basis that there had been an irretrievable breakdown in her relationship with her employer. Following a disciplinary process presided over by a consultant, she was dismissed. The dismissal letter made no mention of her visit to the pub.

In upholding her unfair dismissal complaint, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that the principal reason for her dismissal was the mother’s conviction that she had gone to the pub in breach of the Prime Minister’s guidance and that this, in turn, could impact on her daughter’s health and wellbeing. That amounted to some other substantial reason that could potentially have justified her dismissal.

The Prime Minister had previously warned against congregating in hospitality venues but there was no cogent evidence that the carer heard his speech on the relevant evening. At its highest, people were at that point being encouraged not to gather in pubs and other crowded spaces. Her trip to the local pub was entirely lawful and not in breach of any instruction given to her by her employer.

She had testified that she observed social distancing in the almost empty pub, also using hand sanitiser, and the ET gave some weight to her assertion that she had been at no greater risk of infection than if she had been out shopping. She did not return to work before being placed on furlough the following Monday and her action had thus put her charge at no additional risk.

Given the special nature of personal care relationships, the ET acknowledged that it was not an easy case and cautioned itself against substituting its own view of the carer’s conduct for that of the employer. Overall, however, it found that her dismissal did not fall within the range of responses open to a reasonable employer.

The ET ruled that the amount of the carer’s compensation should be reduced by 20 per cent to take account of her own culpable conduct. Given the Prime Minister’s previous warning, it would have been wise for her stay away from the pub and she could have given a more comprehensive explanation of her conduct during social media exchanges with her employer. The amount of her award would be assessed at a further hearing, if not agreed.

Plagued by Former Employees Turned Competitors? See a Lawyer Today!

Many business owners lie awake at night worrying that senior employees may leave to set up rival operations, taking clients and confidential information with them. Such conduct is, however, highly likely to be unlawful and, as one case showed, specialist lawyers can very swiftly take steps to nip it in the bud. The case concerned a share purchase agreement (SPA), by which a consultancy group acquired the entire issued share capital of a rival company for over £6.4 million. As part of the deal,…

‘Secular Atheism’ a Philosophical Belief Worthy of Human Rights Protection

It is a fundamental feature of any democratic society that anyone can freely express their philosophical beliefs, even if others may find them offensive. An Employment Tribunal (ET) powerfully made that point in the case of a train conductor who was sacked after venting his secular atheist views on social media. In welcoming the reopening of pubs at the end of a COVID-19 lockdown, the man wrote an online post urging people not to let their way of life ‘become some sort of Muslim alcohol-free…

Bar Owner Overturns Liability Finding Following Customer’s Fall on Spilt Drink

Hospitality venues must take reasonable steps to keep their customers reasonably safe – but that is not a counsel of perfection. The High Court powerfully made that point in the case of woman who suffered a painful fracture when she slipped on a spilt drink in a late-night bar. The woman was in a crowded corridor in the bar when she fell in the early hours of the morning, sustaining a broken bone in her foot. She launched a personal injury claim against the bar’s proprietor, alleging negligence…