Capability – Justifying the Dismissal of a Disabled Employee is Never Easy

Justifying the dismissal of a disabled employee on capability grounds is always likely to be an uphill struggle. That was certainly so in the case of an HGV driver who was sacked whilst in the midst of a long and painful recovery from major back surgery.

The operation was serious enough…

May 27, 2022

Pexels ahmet polat 5410923 819x1024

Justifying the dismissal of a disabled employee on capability grounds is always likely to be an uphill struggle. That was certainly so in the case of an HGV driver who was sacked whilst in the midst of a long and painful recovery from major back surgery.

The operation was serious enough to require the driver’s post-surgical treatment in a high dependency unit for three days. For months afterwards he required his wife’s help in climbing stairs and many of the most basic activities of daily life. Although his recovery was initially promising, he continued to suffer debilitating pain and was issued with a blue badge, entitling him to preferential parking.

He was on sick leave when he was dismissed following a capability review. His employer had previously formed the opinion that he was not disabled. His response was to launch Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings, claiming disability discrimination contrary to Section 15 of the Equality Act 2010.

Upholding his claim, the ET found that his condition met the statutory definition of a disability in that it was a physical impairment that had a substantial and long-term effect on his ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. The impairment was likely to last at least 12 months. From what he had told his employer, the latter ought reasonably to have known that he was suffering from a disability.

The employer did not dispute that his dismissal amounted to unfavourable treatment but nevertheless argued that it was justified and proportionate. His continued absence on sick leave had given rise to expense, disruption and uncertainty and the employer had been required to pay another driver to cover his work.

Rejecting those arguments, however, the ET noted that the employer was at the time enjoying increased profits of about £10.4 million a year. None of the costs to which it had allegedly been put due to the driver’s absence were supported by documentary evidence. Given that he was not receiving sick pay when dismissed, there would have been no cost to the employer in retaining him until further medical and occupational health evidence was obtained. If not agreed, the amount of his compensation would be assessed at a further hearing.

Poor Contract Drafting Leaves the Door Wide Open to Employment Disputes

Inept and non-professional drafting of contracts is an open invitation to employment disputes. That was certainly so in a case where a property manager’s contract left substantial room for doubt as to whether he was employed or self-employed. The man was, under the terms of a written contract, for many years engaged by a company to provide site management services in relation to two blocks of flats. He lodged Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings against the company but, in order to succeed in…

High Court Apportions Liability for Worker’s Construction Site Fall

Construction workers often do not have formal employment contracts and, in a world where contractors and subcontractors proliferate, it can be hard to tell where legal responsibility lies in the event of an accident. That was certainly so in a High Court case concerning a labourer who suffered catastrophic injuries in a workplace fall. The worker was engaged in building a mezzanine office at factory premises when he fell onto concrete, fracturing his skull. He suffered a severe brain injury,…

Employment v Self-Employment – This is Why the Distinction Really Matters

Employment law has moved on in leaps and bounds since the bad old days of mass casual labour. However, as an Employment Tribunal (ET) decision showed, a large number of people still go to work every day without any clear idea of whether they are employed or self-employed, or any understanding of why that distinction matters. The case concerned a van driver who worked for the same company (C1) for about 17 years before it was taken over by another (C2). The latter accepted that it was obliged by…