Whistleblowing and the Need to Prove a Causal Link – Guideline Ruling

In order to succeed in a workplace whistleblowing claim, it is not enough merely to prove that you have made a protected disclosure. As one case showed, it is also necessary to establish a causal link between the disclosure and any detrimental treatment to which you have been…

Sep 20, 2021

Armando arauz v bwg0onfmk unsplash 1024x774

In order to succeed in a workplace whistleblowing claim, it is not enough merely to prove that you have made a protected disclosure. As one case showed, it is also necessary to establish a causal link between the disclosure and any detrimental treatment to which you have been subjected.

The case involved a senior employee in a bank’s audit department. In a draft report, she expressed concerns about the bank’s risk exposure arising from a certain legal agreement. There was no dispute that she had made a protected disclosure but the bank denied that it was that which prompted her subsequent dismissal.

The head of the bank’s legal department, who was responsible for the agreement, took strong exception to the employee’s views, considering them an attack on her integrity. There was a discussion and an exchange of emails between them and, prior to the employee’s dismissal, the head of the legal department raised the matter with the bank’s senior managers.

After the employee lodged Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings, her complaint of ordinary unfair dismissal was upheld. The ET also found that one of her complaints of detrimental treatment, relating to the head of the legal department’s conduct, would have been successful had it not been brought too late. Her claim that she was dismissed for whistleblowing was rejected.

Dismissing her challenge to the latter ruling, the Employment Appeal Tribunal noted that the head of the legal department had not participated in the decision to dismiss her. The ET was entitled to conclude that, although the head of the legal department’s conduct towards her was influenced by the protected disclosure, the motivation of the managers who dismissed her was different.

There was no flaw in the ET’s conclusion that the managers were not motivated by the protected disclosure but by the view they took of the employee’s conduct towards the head of the legal department when they met, and in particular in a subsequent email. In their view, the employee had made an unacceptable personal attack on the head of the legal department’s abilities, which reflected a wider problem with the former’s interpersonal skills.

Worker Sacked for Black Lives Matter Comment Wins Unfair Dismissal Claim

Race discrimination is amongst the most sensitive issues that any employer needs to address, and all the more so since the tragic death of George Floyd at the hands of a US police officer and the growth of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in ruling that a supermarket worker was unfairly dismissed for making a comment concerning a black children’s toy. After picking up the soft toy, which appeared to represent a black rabbit, the white British…

Charity Must Pay Compensation Following Hostel Resident’s Window Fall

Those who invite visitors onto their property are obliged to take steps to keep them reasonably safe. As the case of a troubled woman who fell from a hostel window showed, even charities are not exempt from that fundamental duty. The middle-aged woman led a chaotic lifestyle and had a long history of substance addiction and mental health difficulties. One of her legs had been amputated below the knee and she used a wheelchair. She was staying in a hostel run by a charity that provided short-…

School Inspector Sacked for Touching Pupil Succeeds in Unfair Dismissal Claim

It is obviously impractical for employers to have in place disciplinary policies that set out each and every form of frowned-upon conduct. However, as an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruling showed, employees are generally entitled to some forewarning of the types of behaviour that may result in immediate dismissal. The case involved a school inspector who, during an inspection visit, encountered a group of pupils who had come in soaking from the rain. He brushed water from the hair or…