Representing Yourself in Employment Proceedings is a Recipe for Muddle

Those who choose to represent themselves in employment proceedings, without the benefit of legal advice, often have enormous difficulty in getting their real complaints across. That was certainly so in the case of a woman who claimed to have been so badly treated by her employer that she was…

Jun 07, 2022

Pexels marek levak 2265488 1024x683

Those who choose to represent themselves in employment proceedings, without the benefit of legal advice, often have enormous difficulty in getting their real complaints across. That was certainly so in the case of a woman who claimed to have been so badly treated by her employer that she was forced to resign.

The woman had been in her job for less than three months when she resigned. The fees her employer had paid to a recruitment agency when she was taken on – which came to £945 – were deducted from her final wages. Acting in person, she launched proceedings to recover that sum on the basis that the deduction was unlawful. Her claim was rejected by an Employment Tribunal (ET).

Upholding her appeal against that outcome, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) noted that it was her case that she was forced to resign by a manager’s constant criticism, bullying and nit-picking. Such allegations would, to an employment lawyer, have provided obvious grounds for claiming constructive dismissal.

Her allegations of mistreatment were contained in two letters attached to the claim form by which she commenced the proceedings. However, she made no mention of constructive dismissal either in the claim form itself or during the ET hearing. As a result, the ET did not address any such issue.

The EAT found that the ET should have appreciated from the letters that she was, in substance, asserting that she was constructively dismissed. That issue was before the ET and it should have considered whether she had resigned in response to a breach by the employer of the implied term of mutual trust and confidence, thus rendering the deduction of the recruitment fees improper.

The EAT sent the matter back to the same ET for consideration of the question of whether she was constructively dismissed. The employer accepted that, if she succeeded on that issue, the deducted sum would have to be repaid to her. Given the relatively small sum involved, the EAT urged both sides to carefully consider settlement of the dispute as an alternative to further litigation.

Intelligent and High-Achieving Dyslexic People May Still Be Disabled in Law

Dyslexic people may be both highly intelligent and high-achieving but still be disabled in the legal sense of the word. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in a case concerning a worker whose difficulties were such that she could not recall the last time she managed to finish a book. The woman lodged a disability discrimination complaint against her former employer, a university students’ union. To succeed in her claim, she first had to establish that she was disabled within the meaning…

Dismissal for Failure to Disclose Earlier Dismissal Not Unfair

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has rejected a man’s appeal against a decision that he had not been unfairly dismissed for failing to disclose a previous dismissal and a subsequent three-month employment gap on his job application. The man had started working for the Home Office in 2002. In 2016 he was dismissed for gross misconduct. He brought Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings and a conciliation settlement was reached, the terms of which did not alter the basis of his dismissal. In…

Supreme Court Urges ‘Give and Take’ in Town or Village Green Dispute

Town or village greens (TVGs) are effectively sacrosanct against development and public access to them is heavily protected by law. However, they are often privately owned and, as an important Supreme Court ruling showed, that can create some stark conflicts of interest. The case concerned a 200-square-metre area on the quayside of a privately owned port. Entirely covered by concrete and long in use by HGVs and port vehicles, there was nothing bucolic about the site. The port’s owner erected a…