Peculiar Scoring System Rendered Genuine Redundancy Exercise Unfair

A redundancy exercise may be based on reasonable criteria yet flaws in the scoring system used to assess employees’ performance may still render a dismissal unfair. In a case on point, an Employment Tribunal (ET) identified a number of errors and peculiarities in a scoring procedure that led to…

Oct 25, 2022

Rodeo project management software one snucaqq unsplash 1024x683

A redundancy exercise may be based on reasonable criteria yet flaws in the scoring system used to assess employees’ performance may still render a dismissal unfair. In a case on point, an Employment Tribunal (ET) identified a number of errors and peculiarities in a scoring procedure that led to an agency worker wrongly losing his job.

Faced with a business downturn arising from the COVID-19 pandemic, the employer selected a group of eight workers on the basis of their length of service, from which five would be made redundant. There was no dispute that there was a genuine redundancy situation and the ET found that the assessment criteria used for selecting those who would lose their jobs were reasonable.

In nevertheless upholding the worker’s unfair dismissal complaint, the ET found that the scoring system used was so obviously unfair and likely to produce a perverse outcome that it was not within the range of reasonable options open to an employer. Giving an example, the ET noted that the system applied meant that a worker with a poor disciplinary record would keep his job over one with an exemplary record just because the former had completed one simple training course.

Certain criteria were given excessive weight over others and, but for a careless error that was made when scoring his absence record, the worker would have kept his job. The unfairness was far from cured by an appeal process in which radically different criteria were employed. At that stage, he was unfairly penalised in that his strengths in training and team leadership were wholly left out of account.

The ET found no evidence that the worker had been targeted for redundancy due to his outspokenness in making complaints. However, aspects of the scoring process were peculiar or highly unusual and there was circumstantial evidence that one of his colleagues, who kept his job, benefited from some form of favouritism, whether conscious or unconscious. The amount of the worker’s compensation would be assessed at a further hearing, if not agreed.

Sacking Employees for Asserting Their Statutory Rights is Always Unfair

Workers who exercise their entitlement to take a firm stand on their statutory rights may sadly be viewed askance by some employers. However, as an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling made plain, dismissing them for doing so is, as a matter of law, automatically unfair. The case concerned an early-years practitioner who worked for a company that ran a pre-school. Various issues had arisen between her and a director of the company in respect of the calculation of her pay, particularly in the context…

There Is No Duty to Maintain Pedestrian Thoroughfares in Perfect Condition

Highway authorities and private landowners alike are under a legal duty to address tripping hazards so that pedestrians can move around in reasonable safety. As a High Court ruling made plain, however, that is not a counsel of perfection. The case concerned a 64-year-old woman who suffered a nasty fall whilst making her way back to her car after purchasing a newspaper from a local shop. She launched a personal injury claim against the owner of the shop’s forecourt and the local highway…

Dismissal for Failure to Disclose Earlier Dismissal Not Unfair

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has rejected a man’s appeal against a decision that he had not been unfairly dismissed for failing to disclose a previous dismissal and a subsequent three-month employment gap on his job application. The man had started working for the Home Office in 2002. In 2016 he was dismissed for gross misconduct. He brought Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings and a conciliation settlement was reached, the terms of which did not alter the basis of his dismissal. In…