Low Caste Hindu Refused Anonymity Order in Employment Case

The subject matter of Employment Tribunal (ET) cases can be highly sensitive, and those involved are often keen to maintain their anonymity. However, as was shown by a case in which controversial religious issues took centre stage, the open justice principle will usually require them to be…

Nov 18, 2022

Pexels sora shimazaki 5668882 683x1024

The subject matter of Employment Tribunal (ET) cases can be highly sensitive, and those involved are often keen to maintain their anonymity. However, as was shown by a case in which controversial religious issues took centre stage, the open justice principle will usually require them to be identified by name.

The case concerned a senior electrical engineer who was of Tamil origin and came from a low Hindu caste. In ET proceedings he asserted, amongst other things, that his line manager, a high caste Hindu from Mumbai, had discriminated against him on racial grounds. He claimed that his promotion prospects, bonuses and work allocations had all been adversely affected by his low caste status.

In contending that he should be permitted to bring his claim anonymously, he argued that members of his caste are subject to widespread victimisation by higher caste Hindus, both in India and the UK. He contended that, were he to be identified in the proceedings, any resulting publicity could place him, his wife and his children, together with members of his caste generally, at risk of persecution.

Ruling on his application for an anonymity order, the ET accepted that members of his caste do face discrimination by some higher caste Hindus. It was not, however, persuaded that they suffer systematically from threats or acts of violence in this country. His sons were doing very well at school and there was no evidence that they had been threatened, assaulted or victimised by those from upper castes.

In refusing to grant the order sought, the ET concluded that he had failed to provide the clear and cogent evidence required to justify a departure from the fundamental principle of open justice. The ET also rejected the employer’s plea that individuals who would feature as comparators in the case should be granted anonymity.

Parcel Delivery Franchisees ‘Self-Employed’ – Guideline EAT Ruling

A right to substitute someone else to perform your work is perhaps the most powerful indicator that you are self-employed. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) made that point in finding that franchisees engaged by a parcel delivery company enjoyed neither the protected status of an employee nor that of a worker. The case concerned two men who entered into standard-form franchise agreements whereby they were required to provide a vehicle and driver to make collections and deliveries for the…

Gender Transition – Deadnamed Employee Wins Substantial Compensation

Those who undergo the challenging process of gender transition are entitled to their employers’ full understanding and support in establishing their new identity. A local authority which woefully failed in that obligation by persistently deadnaming a transitioning employee was ordered to pay her substantial compensation. The woman gave the council eight months’ notice of her intention to transition. She subsequently launched Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings, alleging numerous acts of direct…

Causation Issue Stymies Assaulted Teacher’s Personal Injury Claim

Employers are required to perform risk assessments and to have policies in place to ensure the reasonable safety of their staff. As a Court of Appeal ruling concerning a pupil’s assault on a teacher showed, however, it can be very difficult to prove that breaches of such duties have caused you injury. The assistant headteacher suffered a fractured cheekbone and psychiatric injuries when the agitated pupil punched him in the face without warning. In the light of the boy’s deteriorating…