ET Lay Member’s LinkedIn Posts Give Rise to Allegation of Apparent Bias

Anyone who serves in a judicial capacity must exercise the greatest care in their use of social media. The point was made by the case of a lay member of an Employment Tribunal (ET) whose posts on LinkedIn gave rise to an allegation of apparent bias.

The member was one of an ET panel of…

Jul 21, 2023

Pexels tracy le blanc 607812 1024x683

Anyone who serves in a judicial capacity must exercise the greatest care in their use of social media. The point was made by the case of a lay member of an Employment Tribunal (ET) whose posts on LinkedIn gave rise to an allegation of apparent bias.

The member was one of an ET panel of three which upheld a woman’s complaints of sexual harassment, sex discrimination, victimisation and unfair dismissal against her former employer. The company was ordered to pay her more than £86,000 in compensation.

Following publication of the ET’s decision, the member used her LinkedIn profile to post a link to a media article about the case. The post garnered some comments to which she responded. In challenging the ET’s decision, the company asserted that the LinkedIn thread created an appearance of bias on her part.

The company contended that, when read as a whole, the thread suggested that she was personally invested in the outcome of the case. The overall impression, it argued, was that she was having a dig at the company and viewed the result of the case as a cause for celebration.

Ruling on the matter, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) emphasised that there was no allegation of actual bias. It was also no part of its role to express a view as to whether what the member did amounted to misconduct in her judicial role. The sole question was whether a fair-minded and informed observer in possession of all the facts would consider that there was a real possibility of bias.

The fact that the posts were made after the ET gave its decision was not necessarily decisive. It was not logically impossible that what a judge or lay member says about a case after it has ended may cast light on how they approached the matter when they were hearing it. That was one reason why they should generally refrain from commenting extra-judicially on their own decisions.

In dismissing the appeal, however, the EAT found that the member’s initial post of a link to the media piece, without further comment, did not give rise to an appearance of bias. In responding to another post, she did pass comment on one aspect of the substance of the case and, by doing so, she headed into potentially dangerous territory. However, on reading that part of the thread, a fair-minded and informed observer would have stopped short of pressing the apparent bias alarm button.

‘Long Covid’ Recognised as a Disability in Important Employment Ruling

Following recovery from the immediate effects of COVID-19, a substantial number of people have gone on to suffer from a phenomenon commonly known as ‘long Covid’. In an important ruling, an Employment Tribunal (ET) found that the condition is capable of amounting to a disability within the meaning of Section 6 of the Equality Act 2010. The case concerned a charity worker who initially suffered mild, flu-like symptoms after contracting the virus. At the end of his isolation period, however, he…

Fear of COVID-19 is Not a Philosophical Belief – Employment Ruling

A fear of contracting COVID-19 or infecting others with the virus is both worthy of respect and readily understandable. However, an Employment Tribunal (ET) has ruled in a novel case that it does not amount to a philosophical belief. The case concerned a woman who said that her wages had been withheld after she declined to return to work in July 2020. She believed that the pandemic at that time continued to pose a serious and imminent health and safety risk. She was worried about contracting…

Wind Turbine Technician Due Compensation for Severed Left Arm

Even the most careful employees can suffer industrial accidents for which even the most safety-conscious employers can be held responsible. The High Court made that point in the case of a technician whose left arm was traumatically amputated whilst he worked on the inner machinery of an offshore wind turbine. The technician, whose reputation for carefulness had earned him the nickname ‘Mr Safety’, was working within the housing of the turbine, which was on board ship and being prepared for…