ET Failed to Consider Context in Victimisation Claim, EAT Rules

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has upheld a woman’s appeal against the dismissal of her complaint of victimisation, finding that the Employment Tribunal (ET) had adopted too narrow a definition of what could constitute a protected act and had not sufficiently analysed the context in which…

Jul 07, 2025

Arpad czapp tvp6pcnq9ii unsplash 1024x768

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has upheld a woman’s appeal against the dismissal of her complaint of victimisation, finding that the Employment Tribunal (ET) had adopted too narrow a definition of what could constitute a protected act and had not sufficiently analysed the context in which the complaint that was said to be a protected act was made.

The woman had worked for a pharmacy business since 2001. In 2018 she moved to another of the business’s stores, where she was the only black employee. The following year, when calling out for the key to the controlled drugs cabinet, she was told by a pharmacist to stop shouting. She brought a grievance in which she claimed that the pharmacist treated her differently from the other staff. Notes from the grievance hearing indicated that, in complaining about the incident when she had been accused of shouting, she had made a reference to it being connected to racial stereotyping.

The COVID-19 pandemic had a significant impact on the woman’s employer and she was eventually made redundant. She subsequently claimed successfully before the ET that she had been unfairly dismissed. However, the ET rejected her claim that she had been victimised because she had complained of race discrimination, finding that she had not made an allegation of discrimination and had therefore not done a protected act.

She appealed the dismissal of her victimisation claim to the EAT, arguing that the ET had erred in ruling out that a race discrimination complaint had been made without taking the step of examining the context.

The EAT considered that case law established that an allegation need not state explicitly that an act of discrimination has occurred. All that is required is that facts are asserted which are capable in law of amounting to an act of discrimination. The EAT noted that the woman had told the ET that she had spoken in the same tone as other colleagues when calling for the key. That should have alerted the ET to the question of why there was a difference in treatment. The law clearly required the ET to consider context: while the ET had found facts that demonstrated the context, it was not clear that it had analysed those facts in terms of how her complaints would have been understood by her employer.

The woman was the only black employee at the store, she had complained of being treated differently as part of a grievance, and the grievance notes raised as an issue that shouting might be connected to a negative racial stereotype. Those facts provided a broad context that the ET was required to consider and analyse. It should have taken account of those factors and asked what the employer would have understood the woman’s complaint to mean from the information she had provided.

Upholding the appeal, the EAT concluded that the claim should be remitted to the same ET, if practicable.

Treating Every Employee in the Same Way May Itself Be Discriminatory

Anti-discrimination laws are often viewed as requiring employers to treat all their staff in the same way. However, as an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling made plain, the positive duty to make reasonable adjustments to cater for disabled workers’ needs may require them to be treated more favourably than their colleagues. The case concerned a quality controller in a food packing plant who was disabled by back pain and depression. He worked 12-hour night shifts in the refrigerated plant and was on…

Is Dismissal a Reasonable Response? It All Depends on Context

When considering whether an employee’s misconduct justifies their dismissal, context is everything. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in the case of a warehouse operative who responded angrily on social media after she was laid off at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. The woman and some of her colleagues were laid off, without pay, shortly before the first lockdown came into force. They formed a closed Facebook Messenger group on which disparaging comments were made about the…

EAT Rejects Unauthorised Deduction from Wages Claim

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has rejected an appeal against the dismissal of an employee’s complaint that unauthorised deductions had been made from his wages because he did not receive an additional day’s pay or a day off in lieu when he worked on bank holidays. The employee’s contract of employment stated that he could be required to work on bank holidays, and that he would be paid at double time for those days and given an alternative day of leave in lieu. When he worked on a bank…