Employment Tribunal Blasts Operations Manager’s ‘Sham’ Redundancy

Employers all too often assert that a worker’s services are no longer needed when the real reason for their dismissal has nothing whatever to do with redundancy. As one case showed, however, employment judges were not born yesterday and are always on the lookout for such shams.

The case…

Dec 21, 2021

Pexels mikael blomkvist 6476808 683x1024

Employers all too often assert that a worker’s services are no longer needed when the real reason for their dismissal has nothing whatever to do with redundancy. As one case showed, however, employment judges were not born yesterday and are always on the lookout for such shams.

The case concerned the former head of operations of an advertising sales company. He worked long hours, often at weekends and during his holidays. He had a difficult relationship with his line manager, however, largely due to the repeated demands that she placed upon him, often at short notice or during his annual leave.

When called to a meeting, he expected to be offered additional support. However, he was instead told that a reorganisation process was afoot, that costs needed to be cut and that his role was to be deleted. Following a series of further meetings, he was dismissed on purported grounds of redundancy. He was told to return his company car, telephone and laptop and his corporate internet and email access were terminated that same day. His internal appeal against dismissal failed.

Upholding his unfair dismissal claim, an Employment Tribunal (ET) concluded that no redundancy situation had in fact arisen. The company’s requirement for the type of work that he performed had not diminished, nor was it expected to do so. The company was apparently performing well and it had presented no figures or accounts in support of the contention that cost savings needed to be made.

The ET found, on the balance of probabilities, that the reason for his dismissal was that his line manager disliked him or because he had challenged her management style and refused to work during his annual leave, as he was entitled to do. She was determined to see the back of him and her sole objective was to terminate his employment under the guise of a redundancy when it was nothing of the sort.

He was not consulted meaningfully and suggestions made by the line manager as to alternative jobs for which he might be suited were insulting to him. The duties he performed still existed and the purported redundancy process was a sham, consisting of several serious procedural irregularities. If not agreed, the amount of his compensation would be assessed at a further hearing.

Employee Bonuses – A Commitment is a Commitment

When it comes to bonuses, commitments made to employees must be honoured. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in coming to the aid of a salesman whose employer prevaricated on its obligation to reward him with a six-figure sum following his successful closure of a multi-million-pound deal. The software salesman and his team spent many months negotiating the deal. His line manager later assured him that he would receive an exceptional six-figure bonus to mark his success and that the…

HSE Encourages Employers to Tackle Workplace Stress

As part of its Working Minds campaign, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has called on employers to support workers’ mental health during Stress Awareness Month. Employers are encouraged to focus on one of the campaign’s five Rs for each week of April. These are:Reach out and have conversations; Recognise the signs and causes of stress; Respond to any risks you have identified; Reflect on actions you have agreed and taken; and Make it Routine.Employers are legally required to prevent…

EAT Upholds Dismissal of Racial Harassment Claim

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has rejected a man’s appeal against the dismissal of his claim for racial harassment on the grounds that the incident did not happen in the course of employment and that his employer had taken all reasonable steps to prevent it. The man worked for an NHS trust as branch secretary of a trade union. A colleague of his who had formerly been a member of the union went to his office during a break from work to discuss the fact that membership subscriptions were…