Employee Bonuses – A Commitment is a Commitment

When it comes to bonuses, commitments made to employees must be honoured. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in coming to the aid of a salesman whose employer prevaricated on its obligation to reward him with a six-figure sum following his successful closure of a multi-million-pound…

Nov 14, 2022

Pexels cytonn photography 955395 1024x684

When it comes to bonuses, commitments made to employees must be honoured. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in coming to the aid of a salesman whose employer prevaricated on its obligation to reward him with a six-figure sum following his successful closure of a multi-million-pound deal.

The software salesman and his team spent many months negotiating the deal. His line manager later assured him that he would receive an exceptional six-figure bonus to mark his success and that the payment had been approved at the highest level. Very soon afterwards, however, his employer underwent a restructuring and the make-up of its senior management team changed significantly.

Only a third of the promised bonus appeared on his payslip following the employer’s receipt of its first payment under the deal and he was informed that payment of the balance would be deferred until a later date. He responded by lodging a grievance and set a deadline for payment of the entire bonus. After that deadline came and went, he resigned and launched ET proceedings alleging constructive unfair dismissal.

Upholding his claim, the ET found that he had every reason to believe that his bonus had been signed off, ultimately by his employer’s then CEO, who left the company shortly afterwards. A binding commitment to pay him the bonus had been made and the ET observed that, if he could not trust his managers to give him accurate information, then whom could he trust?

The ET found that, following the restructuring, the employer had first prevaricated and then reneged on the bonus commitment. It was not open to the employer to unilaterally re-decide the terms on which the bonus would be paid simply because it did not like how much money it would have to pay him.

The employer had no reasonable or proper cause for failing to pay him the bonus as agreed, and his grievance was not dealt with in a satisfactory manner. When the deadline passed, he was entitled to resign on the basis that there had been a fundamental breach of his employment contract. If not agreed, the amount of his compensation would be assessed at a further hearing.

Whistleblowing and the Importance of Proving Motive – Guideline Ruling

Establishing that an employee has made a protected disclosure is the first step on the path to success in any whistleblowing claim. However, as a case concerning a dismissed care homes manager showed, it is often much harder to prove that detrimental treatment is motivated by such a disclosure. The woman had been in post for only about six months when she was dismissed at the end of her probationary period. Her employer asserted that she was dismissed on grounds of capability or performance.…

EAT Reinstates Claims Struck Out for Failure to Comply With Order

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has upheld an appeal against the striking out of a man’s claims after he failed to comply with a case management order, finding that the Employment Tribunal (ET) had failed to consider whether a fair trial was still possible and that an unless order should have been made instead. The man had brought a number of claims including disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment and victimisation. The ET considered that it was not…

Is Dismissal a Reasonable Response? It All Depends on Context

When considering whether an employee’s misconduct justifies their dismissal, context is everything. An Employment Tribunal (ET) made that point in the case of a warehouse operative who responded angrily on social media after she was laid off at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. The woman and some of her colleagues were laid off, without pay, shortly before the first lockdown came into force. They formed a closed Facebook Messenger group on which disparaging comments were made about the…