Restrictive Covenants and Employers’ Legitimate Business Interests

When it comes to considering the enforceability or otherwise of restrictive covenants in employment contracts, judges are required to focus on the need of employers to protect their legitimate business interests. The Court of Appeal emphasised that point in a guideline case.

A software…

Jun 15, 2022

Pexels lukas 574071 1024x678

When it comes to considering the enforceability or otherwise of restrictive covenants in employment contracts, judges are required to focus on the need of employers to protect their legitimate business interests. The Court of Appeal emphasised that point in a guideline case.

A software company sought a pre-trial injunction against a former employee, alleging that he had breached a non-compete covenant in his employment contract. The covenant forbade him from working for a competitor for 12 months following his departure. A judge, however, rejected the company’s application on the basis that it had failed to show that the covenant was more likely than not to be enforceable.

In ruling on the company’s challenge to that outcome, the Court found that the judge erred in his preliminary assessment of the covenant’s enforceability. He took no account of the company’s position that the covenant went no further than was reasonably necessary to protect its legitimate business interests.

The principal factor that the judge took into account against the grant of an injunction was that, if the clause were enforced, the employee, who had family and financial commitments, would not be able to work in his chosen field for 12 months. That factor was not relevant to the preliminary question of whether the covenant was likely to be enforceable and there was no authority for the judge’s approach.

In dismissing the appeal, however, the Court noted that the employee had been in his new job for over seven months. The covenant had only about four more months to run and it was likely that most, if not all, of the damage that the company feared might arise from his employment by an alleged competitor had already been done.

The Court refrained from reaching its own conclusions as to the enforceability of the covenant and ruled that the most sensible course was to maintain the status quo pending a speedy trial of the company’s substantive claim.

Employers – Feelings of Unfairness Cannot Justify Penalising Whistleblowers

Even employers who feel that they have been unfairly criticised have no excuse for targeting whistleblowers for detrimental treatment. An Employment Tribunal (ET) powerfully made that point in the case of a senior care worker who raised welfare and safeguarding concerns affecting residents in a care home. After making the disclosures, both to the care home’s owner and to public healthcare authorities, the woman was suspended. She resigned in the midst of a disciplinary process and launched ET…

HMRC are Clawing Back Furlough Payments Made in Error

It will come as no surprise to hear that HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) is making stern efforts to claw back sums paid in error under the COVID-19 furlough scheme. As one case showed, however, that process has left some reputable and entirely honest employers caught between a rock and a hard place. The case concerned two workers who started employment with a furniture company in late February 2020. Because they were taken on so late in the month, they were not paid for the first time until 26…

Small Employer Pays Heavily for Ignorance of the Acas Code

Ignorance of the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures is a positive invitation to Employment Tribunal (ET) proceedings. A small employer found that out to its cost after a cleaner was sacked by text message. When the woman launched proceedings, the owner of the six-employee business for which she worked contended that she had been dismissed for gross misconduct. He confirmed, however, that he had not followed the Acas Code and that, having never dismissed an employee…